FoL Feedback Thread

oh and yes
adding queen sac -> reddit combo

delete prince

Proceed to remove Unseen
Remove all power roles
Something something marson

ok
Iā€™m going to address this because I understand what the solution is

hint: as long as the game is rolemadness with rigid kp, the game will be swingy

You can try to bite at it
But nothing you do will actually fix issue of blowout games being fairly prevalent

So I could do one of four things to make the swing not super annoying:

  1. Marson joke
  2. Butcher most of the setup
  3. VTs
  4. The Fourth Option

whatā€™s the fourth option

oh and make knight a babysitter instead of an elite bodyguard
either that or REMOVE IT

I made a poll about this earlier

Stop giving a shit about fully removing swing and accept the bullshit that comes with it

Wdym remove it

Knights dont exist

Knight becoming a Babysitter is sorta meh because of the Vig Babysitter strategy

The setup has to be similar to ToL
But it also needs to be more balanced than it currently is

Beyond global reduction in power, thereā€™s no solution that extends games to the point that the game is not going to be decided by d1/n1/d2/(maybe)n2 that keeps the ā€œToLā€ part intact

That relies on other town vig spawning
And no interruption on either knight or other player

You can make similar argument for hunter + drunk

no not that one

the one where you act in such a way that youā€™re likely to get nightkilled (or, you are Vul/Alice) and then target wolfy players

that is not a problem
hunter already exists and you still die

FTFY

I know what youā€™re going for
But Iā€™m going to take it to itā€™s logical extreme

every role punishes scum for any slight mistake they make
and all of them together create a cacophony not dissimilar to an avalanche roaring down a mountain

either babysitter knight, elite bodyguard knight, or something else entirely
because that something else entirely probably strays hard from tol, that creates issues with ā€˜muhtolā€™

Thereā€™s a point at which there are only problems since youā€™re trying to survive being pulled both ways

/vote Geyde

  • Cancel FoL permanently
  • Donā€™t cancel FoL (suggest solution below)

0 voters