I do want him to start posting more. If he’s a player with experience, he should be way more solvey than he has been so far. Lack of familiarity with the setup aside, it’s not like he can’t make social reads on people.
- Marshal asked to be bled
- I did now retribution was removed and I just misread what marshal was saying.
He did solve. He’s pre-flipped me as scum and told me I should “keep that info to myself” because he thinks he knows how to properly play a game where your life is reliant on the correct players guessing who will be attacked at each given night.
Like lets say I am Prince and I make a comment like “Don’t worry, (insert players name) shouldn’t be doing anything tonight”…some players might interpret that as a Butler claim and ignore it. Others players might completely skip over it and ignore it. Few might pick up the potential for this slot to be Prince, but alas…in this current situation only town invests pick it up.
You know who 98% of the time pick it up? Scum, specifically group scum. They bounce ideas off each other. “Do you guys think this is Butler or Prince?” “I say Prince, lets kill tonight.”
Prince dies that night, no heals or protects. Players shouldn’t be softing their class; its much more dangerous than open claiming it. All I did was make him aware of this and he refuses to acknowledge it, then progresses it to a weak case for a scumread.
Also, I asked Wazza to solve and he completely dipped. It’s like Ami when I attacked her early into day 1. I don’t know what they’re doing.
I kinda think Wazza and Ami might both be villagers, because:
- the reactions from both of them (disappearing) are way too dumb and wolfy
- the lack of self-preservation makes them seem like not-neutrals. Neither of them seems fitting to be groupscum, either.
But you did pay enough attention to the thread to respond to my suspicion very quickly. 
Yes because I’m on the thread rn, I’m a boring ass class that’s why I’m interacting in both games.
…Why would he preflip you, and you alone, as wolf, though? Doesn’t it sound like he has mech info on you?
In that case, he’d either be your partner or someone with an unclaimed red peek on you.
It just doesn’t really make sense from a W standpoint. He preflips you as wolf completely at random for no reason?