[Game Thread] Meowntainado (4/14) - Day 5 - Mafia Wins!

/vote cabbage

why is arctic even a wagon? He is like one of the few people playing the game at all.

I kinda realized I went off track a bit by scumreading individual posts and realized that and didnā€™t feel like going back and changing it. Its a mix of both if Iā€™m being honest. Sorry for having such a confusing post. :disappointed_relieved:

Thats good! Let me get on my computer and Iā€™ll properly reply to this.

I did not know this. Thanks.

Let me eat and hop on my computer real quick.

under normal circumstances this would be a pretty stupid reason to defend someone, but the marshal nightkill would suggest that the mafiaā€™s plan is to just kill the louder voices and then win because no one is playing the game

this makes me think my wagon is probably wolf motivated, especially since no one on it has even cased me

if thatā€™s the case then theyā€™re going to have to sacrifice their thread positioning to get me out

Whyā€™d you add me into the POE? Didnā€™t you townread me?

I would but my gut is telling me to keep my vote on you in the small chance of me truly being wrong. If you end up being town then sure I will certainly try and make sure people will listen to you.

I donā€™t think I made read on you, before that and youā€™re highest up in poe

Remove the sure* ^

I mightā€™ve thought wrong, no worries.

/vote cabbage

To those saying I should look into other slots more (@Luxy @Arctic): I do plan on doing that this day cycle. So far, I have focused on my two biggest scumreads, hoping to convince people to vote them.

Although I do have a question to ask @Arctic: you say you arenā€™t convinced my by argument that Emilia is scum, may I ask why?

One more comment om the Emilia business before I move on.

Wendy, if you yourself think you are wrong with a small chance, why not go for the one with larger probability and vite Emilia? What is currently stopping you?

earlier i thought this was reasonable
but arguments like this one donā€™t make much sense from the perspective of you as a villager

why would emilia vote aelin over you as a wolf when they could have just as easily stayed on you or moved back to you since they had much more progression with their read on you than their read on aelin

i think others asked a similar question and this was your answer

the more convenient wagon would have been you, since they had the progression to back it up and iā€™m pretty sure you were more widely scumread, so this doesnā€™t really explain why emilia would vote aelin as a wolf

My answer to this is that in a TvT situation, Emilia did not care for one wagon over the other, and chose the one that was more likely to result in an execution. With you and Luxy on the Aelin wagon as opposed to Aelin and Gorta on mine, I can see how they thought the Aelin wagon was more likely due to more prominent people being on those wagons.

thatā€™s not a bad argument, but i really do think if emilia was a wolf they would have just stuck where they were

this sort of forward planning is above the level of play iā€™d expect from wolf emilia, since as a wolf they well, literally donā€™t play the game
if she were a wolf here i think sheā€™d be too scared to deal with the backlash from going from one villager wagon (assuming youā€™re v for this) to the one that actually goes over

she could have just
avoided having to deal with repercussions by staying on you, and by your logic it would have been more likely for aelin to go over than you, so why would she feel a need to move and make herself look worse if aelin was going over anyway?

You: actually.

When she voted, she could have voted either wagon and it wouldā€™ve been the top wagon; switching would not have been too much effort nor would it have taken much work.

As a counter to your argument, look at her behavior nearer to EoD, when it actually would have looked worse for her to switch votes; she remained on Aelin while scumreading me, and did not care to express any opinions.

Could you elaborate a little further? Sorry if I am not understanding things.

I am also now ashamed at the number of typos I have made in that postā€¦

Player Voted by Votes
cabbage Wendy, an_gorta_pratai, Luxy, Emilia, Hippolytus 5/7
Arctic Arete, Ketsuban 2/7
Arete Wazza 1/7
Emilia cabbage 1/7
Not voting Arctic, EliThePsycho, Marluxion 3

Both majority and plurality are in effect. With 12 players alive, it takes 7 to reach majority.

I can suspect you and Emilia are partnered not only due to interactions but also due to independent scumminessā€¦

I believe you are more wolfy, more so than Emilia. I believe you are able to be W/W and W/V with her. I donā€™t believe sheā€™s W while youā€™re V. Does that make sense?

i am awake
i was going to vote cabbage but then