If those are all of your arguments, I do not believe Aelin should be executed today.
The same argument of feeling unnatural can be made for a lot of other people (myself included), and this kind of read can often be wrong.
Om the other hand, I believe they are more likely to be town; the sudden influx of votes on Aelin (3 votes within 15 posts I believe) would not happen had one of those voters not been scum.
Emilia, who joined this flash wagon with zero explanation so far, is by far the acummiest individual right now.