[Game Thread] Meowntainado (4/14) - Day 5 - Mafia Wins!

[Arete]

@cabbage

I do recognize that your scumread on Marshal is semi-unique; I doubt you are the only one that has doubts on Marshal’s alignments (since, well, I am one of those people), but you are the first one to have voiced your particular reasoning.

I found this post to be mildly townie, it’s not nearly as villagery as I had initially thought (I had slightly misinterpreted it) but I think the attitude specifically in the part of the post that I bolded represents a genuine belief in her reads/them not being totally fake reads that they’re just making up

@Wendy

[Chloe]

Player	Voted by	Votes
Aelin	Arctic, Luxy, Emilia, Arete, Hippolytus	5/8
cabbage	Aelin, an_gorta_pratai, Wendy, Ketsuban, Marshal	5/8
Emilia	cabbage	1/8
Wendy	EliThePsycho	1/8
Arctic	Marluxion	1/8
Not voting	Wazza	1

Both majority and plurality are in effect. With 14 players alive, it takes 8 to reach majority

an_gorta_pratai replaced Grace
Arete replaced Princess_Daisy

Day ends 2021-08-01T21:00:00Z
Postcap is lifted

[EliThePsycho]

/vote cabbage @chloe @sulit
boom bye scum

@cabbage

Why do you hate this?

because it’s like
“i haven’t found a reason to scumread them”
into
“i have confidence they won’t flip scum”

[Marshal]

Go OFF king

[Arctic]

why tf is cabbage saying they have doubts about marshal’s alignment villagery

[Marshal]

EoD wagons are comfy

im fine with this swinging in either direction

[cabbage]

From your wording, I’m not sure if you’re not understanding my post or finding it scummy.
I’ve said that I haven’t found any reason to find Aelin scummy, and I now have evidence against them being scum.

[EliThePsycho]

i find it scummy

[cabbage]

May I ask how exactly you find it scummy?

[Wendy]

@Arete

@cabbage

I do recognize that your scumread on Marshal is semi-unique; I doubt you are the only one that has doubts on Marshal’s alignments ( since, well, I am one of those people ), but you are the first one to have voiced your particular reasoning.

I found this post to be mildly townie, it’s not nearly as villagery as I had initially thought (I had slightly misinterpreted it) but I think the attitude specifically in the part of the post that I bolded represents a genuine belief in her reads/them not being totally fake reads that they’re just making up

@Wendy

I’m a little confused on this, but thank you anyway. Her?

[EliThePsycho]

okay so
what is your evidence against them being scoom

[Arete]

that’s an oversimplification of my point, it’s not just ‘Cabbage has doubts about Marshal, Cabbage town’ but rather the specific way in which they phrase it like an admission (“since, well…”) embedded within their larger post

I think I’m explaining this really badly

[EliThePsycho]

@EliThePsycho

because it’s like
“i haven’t found a reason to scumread them”
into
“i have confidence they won’t flip scum”

[Marshal]

@Wendy

Her?

Arete BTFO by pronoun reads

gottem

[Emilia]

@Marshal

Arete BTFO by pronoun reads

lockwolf

[Arete]

@Wendy

Her?

I have no idea what Cabbage’s gender is but my brain has subconsciously decided they’re a girl

no there is not a good reason for this

apologies if I just misgendered you Cabbage

[cabbage]

I’m…not sure I understand why you find that scummy.

As for my reasoning for seeing Aelin as town, I find it highly unlikely that the subject of a flash wagon with little reasoning behind it (Aelin) is scum.

[Arctic]

@Arete

that’s an oversimplification of my point, it’s not just ‘Cabbage has doubts about Marshal, Cabbage town’ but rather the specific way in which they phrase it like an admission (“since, well…”) embedded within their larger post

I think I’m explaining this really badly

you are
and even then i don’t think it’s villagery
expressing doubt about someone’s alignment gives you plausible deniability for when they flip differently to what your read on them was and thus it should not be interpreted as villagery

[EliThePsycho]

@cabbage

I’m…not sure I understand why you find that scummy.

it’s a big jump
no progression

[Marshal]

@cabbage

with little reasoning behind it (Aelin) is scum.

How is there “little reasoning behind it”

Arctic was a very kind goose man and detailed his case against aelin

I also detailed a seperate meta-based case on aelin.