Nah. King can win in a 2 v 2 . Prince can’t
EVERYONE should be able to lead. Some should just do it a bit better than others but no one should be excluded from trying.
I can lead as a fool. I am so bad as fool… I really want to say the obvious things no one points out
No it isn’t. No class type is designed to “lead” except for King. BD killers are SPOILERS just meant to kill scum at night. There is too many scum to effectively get rid of if you can only lynch.
Prince can lead, but that is because he is nonconvertible and can get claims not because he can kill.
1 Like
Social classes are better placed to lead as everyone can listen to them easier and they are easier to confirm during the day when everyone is listening AND invest classes are meant to lead as they have all the info so everyone can just sheep them.
Killers are the worst placed to lead honestly. They can try make threats to people during the day but I have never once given someone my class who was threatening me because I do it all the time as scum lol.
1 Like
As long as whispers exist anyone can get claims. Leading should never be exclusive to one class as taking the role of leader is half the fun of the game (for me anyways). To properly lead you need at least 1 of 3 things:
A: Confirmability
B: Defense
C: Leverage
The Hunter and King are the only classes which have lots of all 3. And having a phys on you for example doesn’t count. This is about what you can do on your own.
Right now the only BD classes that have none of all 3 of these are Sheriff/Pally and Princess.
1 Like
Oh god we are losing bad I am cold steeling 14
Tried attacking BD
Day 4 and 7 BD are dead
Exactly anyone can lead. Being a good leader has nothing to do with being a Killing class.
I agree that leaders need to be confirmed, which is like I said why Prince, and to a lesser extent Hunter, can be powerful. But lot’s of other classes have that and that’s not related to them being Killers at all.
Your idea that you have to have your own defense to be a leader is bs. To start you are contradicting yourself as Prince has no defense whatsoever. If you are a good enough leader you will clearly be protected.
To answer C, if you are leading BD you will always have leverage during the day to get claims whatever class you are. That leverage is called Lynching! And that kind of Leverage is far more likely to have an impact to get claims or push people as it can be proved and commenced there and then. If a random guy says “oi I’m hunter gimme you’re class” you have to be a moron to give it to him. Even if he is Hunter now he can be converted.
tl;dr This is not true in anyway. It happens that 2/3 BD Killers are easily confirmable so can lead well, which has probably led you to this conclusion.