Harry Potter FM - COMPLETE - DEATH EATERS WIN

[ChopChop]

Claimed Veteran

[CRichard564]

Both Marshal and Alice claimed Veteran that game.
That didn’t have to happen. Then again the past can’t be changed.

[Marshal]

Seth is my toptown atm

italy is not clear to me, he has literally purposefully not made a read yet and the guy is capable of making 40 posts that is a mix of “I will read later” and “insert random off-topic”. Call me when he makes a read.

Eli is not clear to me I cleared him early WYM for being “unfrozen” I think he is capable of doing posts and I dont think the content of his posts are villagery.

I have a light townlean centuries only on his insistence for me to take the leader role because his pregame comments on the player list give the perception that he does not have much faith in post of the players and so wanting me to take a stronger position in-thread fits with that mindset.

I’m still not doing it unless thread needs a leader. I will also do it as a nuclear option if seth gets out of hand and tries to dictate thread but otherwise I like where i’m at.

I think Crichard is tonaly >rand v. That’s basically it. Fairly weak read there’s nothing specific but it’s just what I think.

[CRichard564]

@ridin_with_biden

how do you do fellow zoomers

Mercenary called this slightly scummy and I can see why that’s possible as I’ve seen people with similar opening posts as ridin and they were scum.
Still I wouldn’t call ridin scum because of their opening post which might be NAI for all I know.

@ridin_with_biden

vote marshal with me or you ain’t town

Getting weird vibes from this.
This slot seems eager to push on Marshal for some reason I can’t put my finger on.

@ridin_with_biden

do you have thoughts about the thread

Interacts with Foley, yet no conclusions made about Foley’s answers.
Not liking this slot so far.

@Centuries

Italy I really don’t care enough to read

He has been semi posting stuff which is V AI for him but Null anyway because it’s not enough

Disinterested attitude, which isn’t good for town.

@Centuries

Also I skipped Eli

His whole knowing of the Anti-claim reeks of TMI’ing for scum tbh

Light pointed out there are possible anti claim mechanics.
It could be mistakenly thinking Eli has TMI, though I don’t think Eli has TMI as I think Eli is most likely town.

@ridin_with_biden

Liked app ISO because of how he instatly started solving and seemed rrl invested in it

@Apprentice

Eli isn’t as frozen as a fish in the ice when being scumread by people, is genuinely trying to solve, and has contributed to thread. None of which their previous games have led me to believe they can do comfortably as wolf. No offense to Eli, but I don’t think they can improve their wolfgame that much so quickly

would really want to know where you thought eli was solving

@Apprentice

My townreads rn are Surge, Eli, Italy, Foley in probably that order. I’m still waiting for biden to actually come on and respond to me/do something. Until then my vote isn’t moving

where did italy and foley come in from I cant find any previous mention of them

V lean on this slot for now

Talks about Apprentice instantly solving, though at this point Apprentice seems to be a consensus villager. This might be scum trying to play it safe by making a town read on Apprentice.

Conclusion: I won’t be surprised if this slot isn’t town.
Their attitude doesn’t seem towny and I get weird vibes coming from them.
This is a scum lean.

[Centuries]

@CRichard564

Disinterested attitude, which isn’t good for town.

idk you quoted

@Centuries

Looking at my reads I tackled everything the wrong way

Okay

I still believe Marshal to be townie

@Marshal

I think your point is bad and does not analyze at all what my post intended to do

I think that tonally speaking this post looks better than when I first looked at it

Back then I was kinda angry over getting SR’d for basically just for voicing what I thought about people but whatever

@Marshal

Whatever

This post I still like really think it’s a Town Marshal post because he actually looked at my slot fairly and didn’t act like what I believe scum would act like to be honest, I think the me!wagon is fairly easy to pull off back then especially with the threadstate and the active voices SR’ing me

@Marshal

I just think your first few reads / posts weren’t really productive and it can obviously improve when there are more posts and you can dive in to deeper reasons.

I don’t know if I’m biased towards liking him more due to how his treatment of my slow has been but I still like his slot regardless

@Marshal

Thread is far too passive

Nothing extreme is taking place

There are no stakes
There is no pressure

Wolves are comfortable

I’m really just using this post to say “someone do something please”

I don’t have ideas
Science and spice are outdated and ineffective

Force the wolves to make mistakes
Right now there is nothing that is forcing the wolves into tough spots

I think him complaining about thread state is dumb

You’re supposed to be one of the leading voices, yet your self made post restriction which was supposed to help town is doing the opposite, your voice isn’t being heard

I think just on a pure meta standpoint Seth (Surge) has been fairly pure and I’m honestly not even going to bother reading him beyond “lol!meta” for now

TBE has been a tad too layback for my liking

@TheBlueElixir

no i have not actually analyzed

His product (this game) is what he sold us pre-game, it’s fairly lackluster

The treatment of my slot is kinda off in terms of, effort

Seth’s arguments agaisnt him have been poor and his answers have been… meh

But I’m more-so blaming Seth’s reasoning more-so

I think I don’t like his slot enough for him to escape PoE rn

@TheBlueElixir

app is town

its just a stream of townyiness
and i saw a few things i agree with(surge)

He’s a little adamant on reading people as town which is hngh? I don’t know what to think of the fact he’s willing to just declare someone as town like that, freeflow of thought isn’t impossible for scum apprentice to fake imo.

Looking back I don’t like Merc, which is why my vote is on her

@Mercenary

Here’s my analysis on your vote on me:

You voted at quasirandom because it’s fucking 27 minutes from game start and the vote was casted even before the 27 minutes mark
it was made at random
it says literally nothing about you and you’ll switch your vote later when you have reads anyway

I do believe this is okay tonally speaking

@Mercenary

So you read us both as null but made it sound fancy.

@Mercenary

Anyway Centuries seem for some reason very determinated at scumreading me.

@Mercenary

literal OMGUS?

@Mercenary

your vote really had that TWTBAW feeling

@Mercenary

Centuries is townlean rn.

The progression feels really off.

@Mercenary

I read Surge as town for the following reasons:

This is better but it’s way too much content for the most obv V slot in the game just from a meta standpoint

Maybe I’m biased towards disliking this slot but I don’t really like it rn

@Foley

She forms two reads, one of which is on Centuries, which I think has quite weak reasoning and the other on Surge that had been already building up to consensus.

@Foley

The “pinging for discussion” is useless and comes off more pockety, because the ones that she pings were recently in thread. Especially with doing it on Surge who I at the moment see noone is scum reading.

@Foley

Mercenary is personally a light townlean for me, but it’d follow way more closely towards App’s narrative of it:

This result doesn’t look what you actually read her as? I don’t really know what all of this lead to, how is it a V read

I think a grand amount of it isn’t too AI so far?

Slight W?

Italy I really don’t care enough to read

He has been semi posting stuff which is V AI for him but Null anyway because it’s not enough

@ridin_with_biden

the questions are the buildup

I think this post is cool

Most of it is One-liners and I hate reading them

Rand > V for now

Also I skipped Eli

His whole knowing of the Anti-claim reeks of TMI’ing for scum tbh

Rest has felt pretty okay, I’m skipping him for now and slapping a = rand because I don’t want to, mostly because his posts suck on a, NAI basis and I really hate them

Rest is too low posters

That’s it

from this post

which probably doesnt show me having low wim / interest

@CRichard564

It could be mistakenly thinking Eli has TMI, though I don’t think Eli has TMI as I think Eli is most likely town.

The argument is that Eli knew what the anticlaim was (as in that it was flavor based) before Light saying in thread what the anticlaim was so you could tinfoil him having tmi’d the anticlaim mechanic as scum

it’s etiher that or he asked pre-game in class card what is the anti-claim

[ChopChop]

[CRichard564]

@Centuries

@CRichard564

Disinterested attitude, which isn’t good for town.

idk you quoted

I was talking about ridin with biden’s attitude.
No reason to wait any longer /vote ridin with biden.

[Centuries]

wati i dont understand your quotes

[CRichard564]

So far I’m confident that Apprentice, Surge and Italy are town.
Not a bad D1 so far.
This is getting off to a good start.

[Trochilidae]

Votee	Voter	Votes
Foley	Marshal	1/9
Centuries	EliThePsycho	1/9
Mercenary	Centuries	1/9
ridin_with_biden	Apprentice, Mercenary, Foley, CRichard564	4/9
Italy	ridin_with_biden	1/9
Not voting	Italy, SirDerpsAlot, Surge, PokemonKidRyan, Wazza, Boss110, an_gorta_pratai, Tyron, TheBlueElixir

daily reminder votebot is fed from pings help me im starving

[CRichard564]

@Centuries

@CRichard564

It could be mistakenly thinking Eli has TMI, though I don’t think Eli has TMI as I think Eli is most likely town.

The argument is that Eli knew what the anticlaim was (as in that it was flavor based) before Light saying in thread what the anticlaim was so you could tinfoil him having tmi’d the anticlaim mechanic as scum

it’s etiher that or he asked pre-game in class card what is the anti-claim

Eh maybe, though this argument seems rather weak if you ask me.
I have a feeling biden was scrambling around for an argument to make their shade against Eli more believable.

[Marshal]

Marshal
Surge
Crichard564
Centuries
Mercenary

My town-reads, ranked.

I want to take a deeper dive on Foley soon, there are things I feel like I like about the slot but I have not been able to pin it and want to do that.

@an_gorta_pratai if you are town please share as much reads/thoughts as you can (and answer my question addressed at you earlier, if you need me to quote it I can)

atm I feel iffy on Gorta because his opening wall felt slightly awkward.

weh
gaming
gamer
games
ayaya!

[CRichard564]

I’m tempted to wolf read TBE because of their random votes and their lack of reasons behind their votes.
Yet it doesn’t seem likely that we’re in a world where wolf!TBE would make themselves look suspicious than they want to.
This I don’t care about appearances attitude makes me wonder if TBE is a villager being odd.

[CRichard564]

Think about it.
Wouldn’t wolf!TBE act a bit more cautiously than how they’ve played so far?
The simple answer is yes.

[CRichard564]

This is going to be surprising, yet I think TBE is a slight town read here.
Their I don’t care attitude so far doesn’t make a lot of sense coming from wolf!TBE.
I’ve seen this coming from TBE in FoL 28 with his weird votes on me for starters and he was town that game.

[EliThePsycho]

@Centuries

it’s etiher that or he asked pre-game in class card what is the anti-claim

which is exactly what i did

[an_gorta_pratai]

@Foley

Gorta’s entrance is very lackluster. They have a consensus townread in Surge, but no new original thought process or reason on why they think they are town and then they have a null-read on Centuries with basically promising to improve it later, because they are aware it doesn’t mean much.

The rest is just fluff. I hope this slot delivers later on.

I made one post so far and went to play some Deus Ex. Don’t worry, I may be a bit inactive at times, but if you have been paying attention to my recent games I have been trying harder. I will make more posts today

@Marshal

Why did you post this gorta

this is not a rhetorical question

even if the answer is simple I still do want an answer

It’s a joke, simple as, I have been trying to be a bit looser and less uptight in these games early on instead of going sweaty gamer mode from the get go all the time. You can see this change in WYM when I continued with the Scottish stuff after people complained. I won’t flake on people today, you have my word on that

@ChopChop

If your claims legit, convert me! I don’t wanna be VT anymore!

What claim? Why do you even think there is conversion when the OP doesn’t include anything about it.

@Centuries

Most of it is One-liners and I hate reading them

@CRichard564

with similar opening posts as ridin and they were scum.
Still I wouldn’t call ridin scum because of their opening post which might be NAI for all I know.

@CRichard564

Getting weird vibes from this.
This slot seems eager to push on Marshal for some reason I can’t put my finger on.

I am pretty sure most of those early posts are jokes about Biden’s gaffes. That’s why I am pretty sure the whole “vote Marshal or you ain’t town” thing is a joke.

@Centuries

But the way you’re pushing your read sucks and I hope you realize that fact. Even TBE couldn’t answer your arguments.

Why are you surprised that Seth can’t make convincing arguments? This is how Seth is

@CRichard564

TBE random voting seems more likely town if anything.
Why stir the pot this early in the game as a wolf?
Wolves prefer to not stick out so much and TBE random voting looks more likely to come from a townie than scum.

Derps did the same thing in the last game

@Marshal

@an_gorta_pratai if you are town please share as much reads/thoughts as you can (and answer my question addressed at you earlier, if you need me to quote it I can)

atm I feel iffy on Gorta because his opening wall felt slightly awkward.

@CRichard564

Gorta is an underwhelming slot for today, though their alignment should become clear later on.

I will post today, don’t you worry

[CRichard564]

@EliThePsycho

@Centuries

it’s etiher that or he asked pre-game in class card what is the anti-claim

which is exactly what i did

I mean this was mentioned in the opening post right?

@Aelin

There are flavor anti-claim mechanics in place.

See? It’s on the tin.

[an_gorta_pratai]

I have to put in job applications, so while I am uploading my resume to an email I will be able to interact.

[CRichard564]

@an_gorta_pratai

@CRichard564

TBE random voting seems more likely town if anything.

Why stir the pot this early in the game as a wolf?
Wolves prefer to not stick out so much and TBE random voting looks more likely to come from a townie than scum.

Derps did the same thing in the last game

That’s true except this is TBE I was talking about and TBE has only been this bold when he is town from my previous games with him.