Harry Potter FM - COMPLETE - DEATH EATERS WIN

[Zone_Q11]

Oh hey. Mindmeld.

[EliThePsycho]

here ill quote the post that said the anti-claim mechanics

[EliThePsycho]

in the thread, of course

[Zone_Q11]

I’m too lazy to check.
Quote please.

[EliThePsycho]

@Aelin

@Aelin

There are flavor anti-claim mechanics in place.

This includes your name, your appearance, and your ability name(s), as well as any flavor text.

yee haw

[Marshal]

You never immediately go to someone who replaed in “hey are you VT?” in a serious way

@Aelin

@Aelin

There are flavor anti-claim mechanics in place.

This includes your name, your appearance, and your ability name(s), as well as any flavor text.

flavor vigilantes exist. This does not mean a claim vigilante doesn’t. Every game should be treated as if one exists.

[EliThePsycho]

@Marshal

You never immediately go to someone who replaed in “hey are you VT?” in a serious way

bruh are you sure im not just different

[EliThePsycho]

also as it just so happens i diddly darn gotta go to dinner
sooooooo

[Zone_Q11]

Hm… I see. --I still won’t claim until I get cornered like PKR. (NGL, I am anticipating for a similar situation where even if I claim my role, I will still die.)

[Marshal]

you are lying i’ve been watching you from the windows and you ate dinner 30 minutes ago

caught
scum
dybu
dabu

/vote EliThePsycho

[EliThePsycho]

@Marshal

flavor vigilantes exist. This does not mean a claim vigilante doesn’t. Every game should be treated as if one exists.

i was operating under the assumption
that since it said only flavor in the OP, that means that there is no other anti-claim

[EliThePsycho]

ok bye

[Zone_Q11]

Hey @Mercenary, I skipped 1.5k posts.
Why do you vote Marshal?

[Mercenary]

Wouldn’t it be specified in the OP there would be claimvigs if they bothered writing flavorvigs?

[Mercenary]

[quote=“Mercenary, post:1182, topic:83887”]
He asks early on a lot of questions with no follow-up, then engages in multiple discussions merely to cast doubt on other’s reads.

Summary

[quote=“Marshal, post:252, topic:83887”]

@Centuries

Merc not taking a stand is really whatever I want to say slightly town AI due to idgaf attitude but not too AI either, yes this read based on 4 posts is extremely hedgy and idc

like you don’t explain why not taking a stance or idgaf attitude even is town AI. And like there are so many reasons for / so many explanations for, in first 4 posts, not taking a stance, that it just feels like you pulled this out of thin air rather than ascertained something specific from the posts.

[quote=“Centuries, post:148, topic:83887”]

@ChopChop

I Hardclaim VT.

FML.
I’m now going full try hard because I was given no Night Ability and my only ability is to vote and speak.
[/quote]

Lack of reaction to this by Marshal/Merc who early on mentionned the anti-claim is actually scummy

FoS on them
[/quote]

You missed this post and like that feels like you did not go “ok did merc do this” and look through posts and instead just wanted to make a wolfread.

@Mercenary

Anyway can we stop the mechanics discussion and whether mod bad or not and go back to the game.

And missing it is whatever but you never acknowledged her pointing it out ???

dont even feel like responding to the rest

Whatever
I do not think the way you are formulating reads is productive and I do not think you are giving them more than 5 seconds of thought

I’ll let you keep spitballing

I don’t even wolfread you you had some posts I liked but I think that further down the line (or preferably now) you need to back up your reads with reasoning or I will.

I dont think what you are doing rn is really productive, these really weak early lean / thoughts from experienced players who can fake that as wolf do not do much to actually further the town win condition of catching wolves.

It’s fine to show your thought process but that only helps us read you, it doesn’t help your reads be more effective / start a discussion around them. And I think your current posts are fakeable so I do not really like it so far.

ayaya

@Marshal

@Mercenary

you know what

your vote really had that TWTBAW feeling
I don’t think a wolf would open out OMGUS like that without trying to sound logical

@ridin_with_biden @ChopChop @EliThePsycho @marshal what do you think about this
[/quote]

conroy is a very good wolf and is capable of intentionally faking a lack of logic in reads

I respect his game too much to actually townlrean/read him for this

@Marshal

Wolves are comfortable

…And you make solo reads, although don’t try to engage anyone on them? You just say your reads and don’t seem to want anyone else to get involved on them. As if you wanted to stay at the sidelines.

@Marshal

If anybody thinks RWB is wolf, what reasons do you have for thinking that.

Everyone posted their explanations. This feels like a cheap attempt at looking as if he was making content. It would just make everyone reexplain what they already explained. I don’t see how those questions are useful.

He has little followup on his reads. He scumleaned Apprentice and forgot it, apparently.

@Marshal

My goal this game is to play a support role and town lead only if necessary

So walk to the sidelines.

@Marshal

I’m not going to say more than I think is necessary for the point of being read because i’m capable of faking things to get townread

A bit too self-aware.

@Marshal

Does he really think his ping would cause Derps to post more, or does he want to look better?

This is really stretchy based off only a ping. I can’t see Eli doing it maliciously here. It’s just a prod. Then he keeps insisting on this Eli read without anything new to add (other than people are townreading Eli for his relaxed tone).

@Marshal

Please take a break from thread

On a counterside, I like this post. Marshal isn’t trying to bloat the thread (or let the thread continue to be bloated) or enrage Surge (maybe on fear it would backlash on him).
But I’m also a soft-hearted peb.

He also yet didn’t change any reads on basis of new information.

@Marshal

(although I suppose I probably feel more confident that he is town than centuries)

You said you towncored Centuries a post later Marshal.

At the first time I asked his reasonings he… explains nothing on why he wasn’t putting pressure as he said he would and self-votes. When I question him again, he AtEs.

Conclusion: I started suspecting Marshal because of the vote-and-ate behavior, and kept my vote on him because of his attempt to shift reads, poor progression and trying to look as if he was making effort for the sake of looking townie.

Also his main wolfread (and the Italy towncore read) both had very weak reasoning behind it until he decided to expand on Eli (to push him) one hour from now, I would expect more from Marshal even if he isn’t pushing on purpose. It felt very much like “I need a wolfread now so let’s find someone”.

Basically that

[Trochilidae]

Votee	Voter	Votes
EliThePsycho	Centuries, Marshal	2/8
CRichard564	EliThePsycho	1/8
Marshal	Mercenary	1/8
Not voting	Italy, SirDerpsAlot, Intensify, CRichard564, Wazza, Boss110, ridin_with_biden, an_gorta_pratai, Tyron, Zone_Q11	10

the Trochbot, she is ravenous

[Italy]

trochbot hungers for votes

[Centuries]

so what… ive made my analysis nothing came from it, got ignored

dunno

[Zone_Q11]

@Mercenary

post:1182

Ya, could you please post without the messy codes next time?
Anyhow, let’s see…

@Mercenary

He asks early on a lot of questions with no follow-up, then engages in multiple discussions merely to cast doubt on other’s reads.

This would’ve been a great argument had the singular opponent not been Centuries, whom I had been scumreading.

@Mercenary

@Marshal

Wolves are comfortable

…And you make solo reads, although don’t try to engage anyone on them? You just say your reads and don’t seem to want anyone else to get involved on them. As if you wanted to stay at the sidelines.

Context please. What are solo reads, and whom did Marshal solo read?

@Mercenary

@Marshal

If anybody thinks RWB is wolf, what reasons do you have for thinking that.

Everyone posted their explanations. This feels like a cheap attempt at looking as if he was making content. It would just make everyone reexplain what they already explained. I don’t see how those questions are useful.

I have a problem with the first sentence: “Everyone posted their explanations.”

Who is this “everyone”, and if they scumread RWB, then why was App the only one who stayed on him at EOD1?

---

The others are either one-liners or simply stuff I don’t particularly care about:

• forgetting App scumlead
• walk to sidelines
• self-awareness (since when did this become a scumtell?)
• read on a ping (seems more like a comment from Marshal than an agenda)
• uselessly wasting a paragraph on why “take a break” is good
• something I don’t understand involving Cent and towncore

TLDR: Nope. Still rooting for Marshal. Not liking where you are going, especially after the TWTBAW with Cent.

[Centuries]

Fucking uhh

I still think we should actually look into people who wanted PKR dead after claim because if it’s a claimvig on Seth then wolves lost nothing by yeeting PKR like for real