I feel that his opening was towny. I prefer town to scum like the majority of mafia players do, so I know that sense of relief when you get a towncard, especially after having played scum a lot recently. I think your point is noteworthy, but it’s definitely not enough for me to want to lynch him today.
I think this will probably count for a lot of players here at the moment.
I just said I would’ve said the opposite, that answers your question.
It’s a D1 Townread so it isn’t like ‘This player is Townie for the entire game’, I’m still up for anyone being lynched who isn’t me, including him.
k
If Power Roles out themselves due to a talk about mechanics then that’s their fault. Not mine.
It’s a joke based on what you said to make you realise how stupid it sounded with a different context.
You however did quote it in your post.
However mine was mainly intended towards players who do engage. An example being Marshal who I’m pretty sure was there at the time. Considering everyone ignored me though then that sort of proves to me that the thread was indeed busy.
nope, not really. Not feeling up to it.
The answer is no.
I do not really lurk.
If I am not saying anything I am likely not around.
If I am around I will likely either be posting or typing up a post for the sake of wallposts for example.
All right, why are you scumreading me?
I’d hope we can set the bar higher than anyone else but me. 
Hmm, it’s a lot easier to read for power roles if people talk about them in any context. I’d say the burden is shared, since town is a team.
I have a difficulty with humor occasionally, so that might be my bad, but your entrance example would be unrealistic to have at even an uncrowded time in thread in my opinion.
I am aware, I acknowledged already that that was my bad. I had not read Boss’ post thoroughly enough before I posted.
Now if that was the goal, I would just say Hey Marshal.
That’s unfortunate. It’d be interesting.
who else performatively pinged lowposters or even pinged someone for the purpose of stopping lowposting
(and merc’s pings were definitely not “you arent posting do it now” pings so she doesn’t count)
Oh that’s interesting.
Because you said this to me, when I asked you a question clarifying your Marshal read:
But I had posted this question in a time, where you were absent from thread. This means you weren’t ignoring me at all if you weren’t lurking. However now you say that you don’t lurk. Contradiction.
You probably don’t want it out there in the thread that you’re lurking, because that’s something classically scum would do, so you lie about it here now.
/Vote PokemonKidRyan
This is also a very weak explanation and I think Marshal’s scumrange is bigger than this, given how they have presented themselves. @Marshal Do you play a lot with this player?
No, I literally just missed it because when you get notifications about multiple people replying to a post then you get notifications saying X people replied and it takes you to the first one
| Votee | Voter | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Foley | Marshal | 1/9 |
| Centuries | EliThePsycho, SirDerpsAlot | 2/9 |
| Wazza | ridin_with_biden | 1/9 |
| ridin_with_biden | Apprentice, Mercenary, CRichard564 | 3/9 |
| an_gorta_pratai | Surge | 1/9 |
| SirDerpsAlot | Centuries, Italy | 1/9 |
| PokemonKidRyan | Foley | 1/9 |
| Not voting | PokemonKidRyan, Wazza, Boss110, an_gorta_pratai, Tyron, TheBlueElixir | 6 |
I’ve played with him before
This isn’t uncommon for villa!him
I don’t really know on him this game tbh, he’s not overly easy to sort, but PKR can do some ??? stuff as villa like that and is capable of more or less faking it as wolf.
Would’ve
Remember, this is D1, my reads mean nothing as I don’t care about them myself.
Sure.
It’s not my fault if we’re talking about mechanics and then a PR is like “hello I’m pr”
that’s because it was a joke- you know what, nevermind.
I wouldn’t as that’s just random and off-topic which you just said not to do.
still no.
Me and Foley are reading each others. Idc about the rest of you.
I don’t buy it. You should not feel obliged to even apologize when you “miss” a post. You instead used the wording of completely ignoring.
You answered relatively fast with this, so that’s a slightly better look, but not enough for me to want to switch my vote. Can you provide me with some scumreads?
What makes day 2 so different from day 1. Reading is just the same, but you have slightly more information. You’re still going to be acting on incomplete information at all times.
If you have a read on me that’s interesting, then I’d like to hear it, because it’d help me sort your slot and potentially remove you from the players I want to lynch this day.
A PR can be outed in more ways than them hardclaiming their role in thread. Simply talking about mechanics or PRs allows scum to fish who is a PR or not. I’m sure that this conversation is doing the same, but I think I’ve handled myself interestingly enough to keep them guessing. 
It’d be Hey Marshal, [insert on-topic thing].
But… it’d be sooo interesting… aahhh. Pretty please?
Yes, these posts aren’t really towards anyone else’s benefit for the present moment and talking about how smart engaging further with these posts is, I’ll be happy to discuss post game.
Mechanics.
I’ll pass on reads for today, I’ll place a vote on my top scumread shortly. (Or at least I might, depends if I remember or not)
you clearly aren’t from these forums as this never works like this.
that’s just awkward and strange .
n, o, spells no.
I never thought it was. Some people can just blend in better
I think I am willing to town leadn this
I am working on that
Do you have any scum reads currently?
Why in the hell am I so high on your list when even I know I haven’t done anything much?
I scumread this, I know it’s likely a joke, but there is anti-claim and I don’t think a villager would claim their flavor like that
I think your catchups posts have been a bit weaker this game actually
There’s no real analysis I feel
You had good tone in your first few posts also
This post I agree with
