Harry Potter FM - COMPLETE - DEATH EATERS WIN

[Foley]

@PokemonKidRyan

The answer is no.
I do not really lurk.
If I am not saying anything I am likely not around.

If I am around I will likely either be posting or typing up a post for the sake of wallposts for example.

Oh that’s interesting.

Because you said this to me, when I asked you a question clarifying your Marshal read:

@PokemonKidRyan

I apologise for completely ignoring your post but…
Relaxed opener, reiterating to stop claim vigilantes or whatever mechanic scum has access to

I feel like Marshal was just joking around early and that is sorta what I expect a lot of them. Nothing overtly serious. Some questioning, some good posts but nothing which would like stand out too much without ISO diving.

@PokemonKidRyan

I apologise for completely ignoring your post but…

But I had posted this question in a time, where you were absent from thread. This means you weren’t ignoring me at all if you weren’t lurking. However now you say that you don’t lurk. Contradiction.

You probably don’t want it out there in the thread that you’re lurking, because that’s something classically scum would do, so you lie about it here now.

/Vote PokemonKidRyan

[Foley]

@PokemonKidRyan

So far I think Light is town lean and Marshal too since Marshal has had quite a natural thread presence.

@PokemonKidRyan

I apologise for completely ignoring your post but…
Relaxed opener, reiterating to stop claim vigilantes or whatever mechanic scum has access to

I feel like Marshal was just joking around early and that is sorta what I expect a lot of them. Nothing overtly serious. Some questioning, some good posts but nothing which would like stand out too much without ISO diving.

This is also a very weak explanation and I think Marshal’s scumrange is bigger than this, given how they have presented themselves. @Marshal Do you play a lot with this player?

[PokemonKidRyan]

No, I literally just missed it because when you get notifications about multiple people replying to a post then you get notifications saying X people replied and it takes you to the first one

[PokemonKidRyan]

@Foley

Do you play a lot with this player?

We play often enough.
He is an active forumer, I am fairly active.

[Amelia]

Votee	Voter	Votes
Foley	Marshal	1/9
Centuries	EliThePsycho, SirDerpsAlot	2/9
Wazza	ridin_with_biden	1/9
ridin_with_biden	Apprentice, Mercenary, CRichard564	3/9
an_gorta_pratai	Surge	1/9
SirDerpsAlot	Centuries, Italy	1/9
PokemonKidRyan	Foley	1/9
Not voting	PokemonKidRyan, Wazza, Boss110, an_gorta_pratai, Tyron, TheBlueElixir	6

[Marshal]

I’ve played with him before

This isn’t uncommon for villa!him

@PokemonKidRyan

I mean, Marshal basically mind melded with me when it came to my idea for the word bank so in my eyes I think Marsh is good.

@PokemonKidRyan

We literally posted at almost the same time.
Also, I posted earlier than I wanted.
My idea was to go back and say what everyone else had done so thus far in order

@PokemonKidRyan

I was not around at the time so I was unaware Marshal did any other list.
I saw myself and Marshal post at the same time so I thought it was a weird af mind meld

@PokemonKidRyan

Well since FoL 30 has concluded, my obligation to try and do stuff with very little mechanical info is done. So hey there, I am here now.

One thing we can speculate is who would choose wolf or wolves.
I cannot remember which it was.

But, the main targets for this would be like the massive contributors and myself due to lol Furry wolf boy.

I could easily see a team with low posters or low thread presence people atm.

@PokemonKidRyan

Thank you, this is the reaction I wanted from someone and you shown it.

I don’t really know on him this game tbh, he’s not overly easy to sort, but PKR can do some ??? stuff as villa like that and is capable of more or less faking it as wolf.

[Foley]

Their reasons were much stronger there than here

[Wazza]

@Foley

All right, why are you scumreading me?

Would’ve

Remember, this is D1, my reads mean nothing as I don’t care about them myself.

@Foley

I’d hope we can set the bar higher than anyone else but me.

Sure.

@Foley

Hmm, it’s a lot easier to read for power roles if people talk about them in any context. I’d say the burden is shared, since town is a team.

It’s not my fault if we’re talking about mechanics and then a PR is like “hello I’m pr”

@Foley

I have a difficulty with humor occasionally, so that might be my bad, but your entrance example would be unrealistic to have at even an uncrowded time in thread in my opinion.

that’s because it was a joke- you know what, nevermind.

@Foley

Now if that was the goal, I would just say Hey Marshal.

I wouldn’t as that’s just random and off-topic which you just said not to do.

@Foley

That’s unfortunate. It’d be interesting.

still no.

@SirDerpsAlot

Chill with the wall posts no one reads em

Me and Foley are reading each others. Idc about the rest of you.

[Foley]

@PokemonKidRyan

No, I literally just missed it because when you get notifications about multiple people replying to a post then you get notifications saying X people replied and it takes you to the first one

I don’t buy it. You should not feel obliged to even apologize when you “miss” a post. You instead used the wording of completely ignoring.

@PokemonKidRyan

I apologise for completely ignoring your post but…

You answered relatively fast with this, so that’s a slightly better look, but not enough for me to want to switch my vote. Can you provide me with some scumreads?

[Foley]

@Wazza

@Foley

All right, why are you scumreading me?

Would’ve

Remember, this is D1, my reads mean nothing as I don’t care about them myself.

What makes day 2 so different from day 1. Reading is just the same, but you have slightly more information. You’re still going to be acting on incomplete information at all times.

If you have a read on me that’s interesting, then I’d like to hear it, because it’d help me sort your slot and potentially remove you from the players I want to lynch this day.

@Wazza

@Foley

Hmm, it’s a lot easier to read for power roles if people talk about them in any context. I’d say the burden is shared, since town is a team.

It’s not my fault if we’re talking about mechanics and then a PR is like “hello I’m pr”

A PR can be outed in more ways than them hardclaiming their role in thread. Simply talking about mechanics or PRs allows scum to fish who is a PR or not. I’m sure that this conversation is doing the same, but I think I’ve handled myself interestingly enough to keep them guessing.

@Wazza

@Foley

Now if that was the goal, I would just say Hey Marshal.

I wouldn’t as that’s just random and off-topic which you just said not to do.

It’d be Hey Marshal, [insert on-topic thing].

@Wazza

@Foley

That’s unfortunate. It’d be interesting.

still no.

But… it’d be sooo interesting… aahhh. Pretty please?

@Wazza

@SirDerpsAlot

Chill with the wall posts no one reads em

Me and Foley are reading each others. Idc about the rest of you.

Yes, these posts aren’t really towards anyone else’s benefit for the present moment and talking about how smart engaging further with these posts is, I’ll be happy to discuss post game.

[Wazza]

@Foley

What makes day 2 so different from day 1. Reading is just the same, but you have slightly more information. You’re still going to be acting on incomplete information at all times.

Mechanics.

@Foley

If you have a read on me that’s interesting, then I’d like to hear it, because it’d help me sort your slot and potentially remove you from the players I want to lynch this day.

I’ll pass on reads for today, I’ll place a vote on my top scumread shortly. (Or at least I might, depends if I remember or not)

@Foley

A PR can be outed in more ways than them hardclaiming their role in thread. Simply talking about mechanics or PRs allows scum to fish who is a PR or not. I’m sure that this conversation is doing the same, but I think I’ve handled myself interestingly enough to keep them guessing.

you clearly aren’t from these forums as this never works like this.

@Foley

It’d be Hey Marshal, [insert on-topic thing].

that’s just awkward and strange .

@Foley

But… it’d be sooo interesting… aahhh. Pretty please?

n, o, spells no.

[Centuries]

@Tyron, anything to say? I’ve been waiting for your posts for a while

[an_gorta_pratai]

@CRichard564

This isn’t said to make fun of Surge.

I never thought it was. Some people can just blend in better

@CRichard564

It’s true that the likes of Alice can pass themselves off as town as naturally as us breathing.
Though those sort of players are rare, and if every town player makes an effort to chip in and get discussion going, that alone would ensure a lot less mislynches in the PoE.

@CRichard564

I should also add one more comment in reply to Gorta’s post.
If townies made an effort to get out of PoE and not just lie down and die ala Wild West FM, then it’s much harder for wolves to escape the PoE and avoids town stomps as in Wild West FM.

I think I am willing to town leadn this

@Marshal

I have outright on Eli / TBE / Gorta, not just like PoE or people I think contain tons of wolves but people I want to focus.

Gorta should clear up if / when more posts from him come

I am working on that

@ChopChop

/Vote Gorta

Null Read.
I like allot of other people more.
My two Scum Reads don’t seem to be on anyone’s agenda to lynch today so meh.

Do you have any scum reads currently?

@Centuries

Townier
Centuries
Seth
Marshal
CRich
Apprentice
Gorta
Boss
Ridin
Italy
Eli
Tyron
Null read
PKR
TBE
Wazza
SDA
Foley
Merc
Scummier

Why in the hell am I so high on your list when even I know I haven’t done anything much?

@SirDerpsAlot

Also

Hardclaiming Harry Potter

I scumread this, I know it’s likely a joke, but there is anti-claim and I don’t think a villager would claim their flavor like that

[Centuries]

I think your catchups posts have been a bit weaker this game actually

There’s no real analysis I feel

@an_gorta_pratai

Why in the hell am I so high on your list when even I know I haven’t done anything much?

You had good tone in your first few posts also

@Boss110

It’s something that I only see town would say because wolf gain nothing out of this. A bit off-topic, but it is true nonetheless.
Anyway, that’s all for today. I want to see more from Gorta as he seems eager to read and do thing. Night.

This post I agree with

[an_gorta_pratai]

@Centuries

I think your catchups posts have been a bit weaker this game actually

There’s no real analysis I feel

I have been skimming the thread, but I plan to do more analysis posts when I make reads

[an_gorta_pratai]

My analysis won’t be amazing when I am skimming the thread. I learned from Marshal that it’s better to interact and that skimming the thread and going back to read certain things is always better

[Wazza]

@an_gorta_pratai

Why in the hell am I so high on your list when even I know I haven’t done anything much?

tbh his reads seem pretty bad.

[Wazza]

They just seem thrown together and that’s coming from a guy who’s notorious for throwing reads together.

[Centuries]

how so?

[SirDerpsAlot]

@an_gorta_pratai

I scumread this, I know it’s likely a joke, but there is anti-claim and I don’t think a villager would claim their flavor like that

In immune to anticlaim