Not ALL of the FoL things should be added. Cult points is another example of things that work in FoL but not ToL. Same with the reduced feedback.
However both games can learn from each other
Agreed, but instead of replacing nightshade rupture should give poison instead. It might be a bit confusing since bleed is already a night ability for hunter. And they should have different mechanics.
Thatās the point. Itās too easy to tell what the evil faction is early game. SHeriff and paladin need changes as well.
Thatās why I said they should be different mechanics. Bleeding should be a night ability which kills in one night, and poison a day ability that kills in 2.
Honestly. Thatās missing the point. Bleed was chosen because it makes the heal message the same. The idea being that if you get creative you could do something fancy to get people killed.
1 Like
The heal message could just be changed to a general āyou cured your targetās woundsā then to prevent that.
3 Likes
What if a new neutral killer was introduced with a non-nightshade poison. this could bring differences between phys and alch (say phys can remove the poison by drawing it out, but the alchās potions donāt cure it). this would make phys feel stronger than alchs, and make town more reliant on phys.
It may also make phys feel more useful, possible helping to stop complaints (although that will never happen completely)
While that would be cool it isnāt really part of this suggestion thread.
The physician isnāt actually weak or even boring like CW used to be. Her problem is being to common which makes people burn out and want something else. These suggestions are trying to make it so we can reduce healer frequency and increase the distinction between healers.
2 Likes
(say phys can remove the poison by drawing it out, but the alchās potions donāt cure it)
But this would make it easier to tell if someone is alch as opposed to phys.
Wait this reminds me.
Doesnāt anyone else like claiming alch as herbalist. I HAVE CONFIRMED HEALS I CANT BE CONVERTED ALSO 
3 Likes
Not a fan of delayed kills at all
Maybe if it was a usual NK with some bleeds or something but just a poisoner seems like a very bad move
1 Like
Most players would only heal themself.
2 Likes
Iād honestly like to see bleeding and poison have slightly different effects instead of being the same effect with different names.
2 Likes
Honestly I would just never claim alch and always claim some random class tbh and always heal myself.
Like hunter.
But livicus that would make the alchs winrate skyrocket in games without reaper.
Donāt think you understand the magical power of healing yourself constantly and no one can do a thing about it. (Except occupy/execution but whatever)
Ehh Blue Dragon usually executes Alchemists anyway.
2 Likes