Last Poster Before Threadlock gets a cookie (cookie thread v2)

Off-Topic (Thronepass)
#19332

It should be removed

#19333

Inquisitor aims at preventing claims
It’s not doing that, it’s a failure and needs removed imo

#19334

At least it isn’t ToL inquisitor

Where being a heretic mech confirms the person

2 Likes
#19335

I also think ‘true’ neutrals shouldn’t exist if neutral conversion would be implemented
Only neutral good and neutral evil

#19336

Removal of true neutrals I suppose to answer that

#19337

I’m pretty sure the last two times we’ve had an open Scorned we let them live

to be fair in both cases BD was in a position where doing so was optimal, and in one case they were mechanically confirmed as Scorned

2 Likes
#19338

Why does Happy Hour bypass occupation immunity by the way?
That’s also ridiculous

#19339

From my point of view leaving Scorned alive is never optimal unless its late late game, since I don’t need them messing up my investigatives but you’ve seen the average level of BD play in the games we played yesterday.

1 Like
#19340

that’s fair
(tbh I personally hate true neutrals because they inevitably swing one way or the other)

1 Like
#19341

fixed that for you

#19342

it doesn’t

it just removes the immunity first :wink:

1 Like
#19343

‘hey the dead Sheriff found this person Unseen’

‘we can either vote Mastermind candidates or vote the outed wolf’

everyone: doesn’t vote anyone

#19344

immunities should never be absolute tbh

unless we are talking about disease

#19345

While I’m forced to stay alive until the very end to behold that idiocy.

1 Like
#19346

I want neutrals to be in two categories:

  • Neutrals BD want to keep alive and don’t want to waste KP on as they will always benefit BD.
  • Neutrals who are exclusively evil. This also has to benefit NK as well as Unseen/Cult
#19347

here’s an idea
I’ll run an EFoL with your suggestions if I get off my ass and actually work on it (plus I kind of lack the concepts to make this work)

I think idea has some merit

1 Like
#19348

in one of the games it was D3 but based on the number of BD who were dead (including the Prince) we were in a position where even if we lynched scum literally every day we could still lose

in the other it was D2 but it was a super scumsided EFoL set-up (like, so scumsided that evils, on their own, had more than majority on D3 without any form of vote manipulation)

so like

not lategame by day count but lategame by BD’s position

#19349

could you reply to this post with one that fits into each respective category

#19350

Also what is this

Why does it seem like the only use this would ever have is using it on King’s guards but haha
You are the king

#19351

in the first case the Scorned was also mechanically confirmed

one of the issues with leaving Scorned claims alive in ToL is that sometimes they’re evils whose logs were proven fake