(Misc) Blood on the Forums III: Moonlight Badness (Good Wins)

Forum Matches Completed
#1019

…crap. I just realized a stupid way to force me to live.

Uh… right. For starters, I need to confirm something.

/whisper @Apprentice

#1020

whoops

missed SoD and the mech speculation around it

uh

I wanna say its slightly more likely to be a pukka game because of death count but I dont think knowing which really helps besides for a courtier, and it should become more obvious with more time, but IMO courtiers shouldnt yolo n2 anyway if they want to do it on the Demon(which they should)

slightly more likely pukka, less likely zombuul or the Shabboth?(you know which I mean) and Po could still go either way is about all we can get from it. Speculating further on ‘but XYZ Po slightly likely’ wont get us anywhere, so lets take what we can and not mess with specifics.

so yes I just speculated while saying speculating useless thank me later

The whole Kyo/SDA thing

looking at all of these:

gambler is not the best here. Particularly without claims. For earlier on, trying to get something like a grandmother’s n0 or a Tea Lady or Professor would be infinitely better, particularly before a Professor rezes or a courtier…courts

gambler is only strong when they have preferably alot of claims to work with, and its been made clear claiming its -EV by vets so that would probably never happen

I dont think killing someone for being gambler makes sense. Dunno if you gave any reads but they might be useful to look back on.

also I didnt think you read all of the classes so I had a thought somewhere you were gambler without you claiming it with this post so your point may not even apply

since there is no scumchat this doesnt clear kyo but I dont think it makes sense to SR kyo for it? Not all scum decide who die, but if Kyo is a scum who decides who die, I think they wouldnt attack SDA. But there was more then 1 kill anyway, and this goes nowhere, but it shouldnt warrant a SR.

I have no clue why in this world of the next SDA was killed but I dont think it was on claim. Could just be WiFoM or literally marson-level RNG, we dont know, and the more people act like they do the less sense it makes. Just stop it. Giving only SDA a pass for obvious reasons.

oh and on a note about zone - their town

I did have a little thought d1 that I didnt express for somewhat obvious reasons because they were tryharding a bit but their lust for death just fits into their lolmeta also claim will make it obvious it very obvious point or another anyway

the SDA logic could apply to app but I think? App has made a few reads in his lifespan, and someone getting killed for reads makes more sense so ill take their reads a little more accurate(they can be wrong, but mightve been right on a crucial spot) then I mightve otherwise

lemme ISO to find some of those

App's Reads

https://forum.imperium42.com/t/misc-blood-on-the-forums-iii-moonlight-badness-day-2-discussion-phase-11-14/82181/138?u=theblueelixir

not really a read but it would be a motive for Zone? But I think zone’s town anyway

also this was a clarified joke by EoD anyway

https://forum.imperium42.com/t/misc-blood-on-the-forums-iii-moonlight-badness-day-2-discussion-phase-11-14/82181/183?u=theblueelixir

this…was also a joke

well it looks like it

I dont think they got killed for this

https://forum.imperium42.com/t/misc-blood-on-the-forums-iii-moonlight-badness-day-2-discussion-phase-11-14/82181/320?u=theblueelixir

again, maybe this makes L1ght look a little better, but it doesnt actually point to scum

…and thats it. So they werent killed for their reads I guess. welp, b r u h

#1021

Wait what why did the day start so early wth

#1022

Also I think I’m going to go read the OP because Arete is dead and talking (and ig SDA and App)

1 Like
#1023

Well
The dead can speak

#1024

I have read the OP! Magic~

Okay, that only makes it 100% that we should’ve killed Arete yesterday, and it’s now kinda weird that N was so opposed to it.

[VFM] SFoL -1: Hall of the Incendiary - Night 6 - Cult wins!
#1025

my logic was that even if arete was telling the truth, killing them was less +EV for town than other possible moves such as killing evils, since there’s probably a godfather afoot

#1026

The evils we would magically know, yes?

#1027

I will be on later

#1028

no
but imo it’s better to hunt for them than waste a day on a goon that may or may not be real

#1029

we’ve already lost if arete is a liar but there’s no choice but to look elsewhere
which is annoying

#1030

if goon gets converted they get parity at 10 players

thats insane

what pulled me over, anyway

#1031

the game does not end at parity

#1032

the game does not end until the Demon (+Possible MM combo) is dead, we reach F2, or everyone alive is evil before f2.

#1033

ye

but its incredibly difficult to overcome, even with dead player’s votes

#1034

false
so long as there’s someone good alive capable of nominating the demon, good always has a chance

#1035

So what I’m getting from this is you’re one of kyos minions

#1036

Do evils here have fakeclaims?

#1037

Tow slip denied lmao

#1038

It’s not a townslip
It’s because I think it’s entirely plausible you’re Zombuul that had an Assassin kill you
LOL