[Misc] Blood on the Forums IV: Glimpse of the Future (Evil Wins)

[katze]

i have a question

if we had to exile 3 travelers today which 3 would they be, in order

this is directed towards anybody

[KyoDaz]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U06jlgpMtQs

[Redrover1760]

@Redrover1760

@Icibalus

Anyway, all hail the Travellers Of Haven! Together, we shall create a new utopia!

@Icibalus

with my special power of GUN nobody could possibly stop us!

@Icibalus

I’m a villager because this role being given to a wolf would break the setup. You’re welcome.

Actually I’m pretty sure this is evil traveler.

@Icibalus

Amelia’s allignment is up in the air based on storyteller intention. And I have no idea what’s going on with Wazza.

@Icibalus

It’s more that Wazza chooses which, of any, dies, because meta says that it’s usually best to lynch whenever possible.

@Icibalus

see i’m more worried about deviant

deviant should only be given to a TRUE funnyman

@Icibalus

regrettably mechanics are neccecary to solve this game

but i shall do my best to drop some SICK reads

This is basically every suspicious or non-mechanical statement Icibalus has said so far.

Like this is what Icibalus has said so far.

[katze]

and why*

anyone who says katze gets scumread by me btw

[KyoDaz]

If Icibalus is evil this game is broken
Literally broken

[Napoleon]

I would keep Amelia. One of Italy/katze. Rest can go bye-bye.

[Redrover1760]

So your confirmation of Icibalus is a 100% Mechanical Confirmation.

I swear, someone should learn that there is no such thing as 100% Mechanical Confirmation actually meaning anything. Especially when there isn’t a mechanical confirmation. There could easily be like 4 town 1 evil traveler and the 1 evil is Icibalus.

[Redrover1760]

Especially when the steps to exile Icibalus is that simple.

[katze]

@Napoleon

I would keep Amelia

why amelia specifically?

@Redrover1760

no such thing as 100% Mechanical Confirmation actually meaning anything

innocent children would like to speak to you

although i do agree that kyos argument is eh

[KyoDaz]

Aanddd town would have no KP if that was the case
Storyteller would be our KP nominations

[Napoleon]

bc i townread her

[Redrover1760]

Storyteller must always nominate one of the other alignment. So there will always be at least 1 town/1 wolf in the list.

[Napoleon]

I wonder how many they will nominate

[Napoleon]

@Redrover1760

other alignment

i interpreted this as “opposite”

[Redrover1760]

@N.1

Bis hop : The Storyteller makes all nominations. At least one player opposed to your alignment must be nominated each day.

Nevermind.

[Redrover1760]

If the Bishop is Good that means there will always be one scum on the list, which is most certainly the case if Icibalus is scum.

[Geyde]

Got shit to do

[KyoDaz]

That is possible, but I townread Icibalus

[katze]

@N.1

Italy (Traveler – Bishop)
Wazza (Traveler – Voudon)
Amelia (Traveler – Matron)
Icibalus (Traveler – Icibalus)
katze (Traveler – Deviant)

what each traveler in play does

@N.1

Icib alus : Kill one of the two living players next to you each day, but only if the other neighboring living player agrees first (either publicly or within whispers). If one of your neighbors consents, you may kill the other. A neighbor’s consent does not affect your ability to kill that person, only the opposing neighbor (this must be the first traveler that appears in the game by whatever means necessary. Players can choose the one they want for all the rest but ST chooses the additional ones if the Priestess ability activates) .

@N.1

Mat ron : Up to thrice per day, you may publicly choose two players; these players swap positions. Players may only whisper their neighbors.

@N.1

Bis hop : The Storyteller makes all nominations. At least one player opposed to your alignment must be nominated each day.

@N.1

Vou don : Only you and the dead may vote on executions. The dead do not spend a vote token to vote, and do not require one. A 50% majority is not required for an execution.

@N.1

Dev iant : If either or both of the Storytellers laughed as a result of any of your posts in the public thread today (we will be honest), all attempts to exile you for the remainder of the day will fail.

if we’re gonna use “X can’t be evil because it’d be unbalanced” as a defense then i think Wazza/Icibalus are the least likely travelers to be evil

if we assume 2 travelers are evil then FMPOV Italy/Amelia is pretty likely to be evil

but i also think this is a silly argument and that traveler alignments are randed, the only possible exeception being icibalus but eh…

[KyoDaz]

I feel like Deviant is one of those travelers which doesn’t impact town’s winrate by a lot but can severely unbalance evil’s winrate
Don’t feel like Deviant is evil here, but it’s possible