[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

So the only possible sources of information malfunctioning is Viceroy, Reveler and Bogman right?

This kind of weirds me out playing BotC on a forum after playing so much traditional BotC

So therefore we have two worlds

PKR was poisoned by a Viceroy, therefore we know cloned is getting good info. And therefore one of Intensify and Whysper is the demon

And we have the world where I’m evil, and intensify and Whysper are both not the demon

I feel like I should make reads here

So therefore, we should kill Intensify and Whysper and if the game doesn’t end I’m basically confirmed as evil no?

Unless we have a chieftan and eclipse in which case fuck me I guess

My only problem with that is by that point it’s down to 3, which is a must lynch situation. If the demon isn’t in you 3 then the evils win

No it wouldn’t. Because I’m good therefore one of Intensify and Whysper have to be the demon

Since I know PKR was probably poisoned by the Viceroy, and we know it’s probably a retrogradus game. That removes all sources of ability malfunctioning in game. So that just leaves Insanity and Whysper as being the demon

So if we don’t have a chieftan. The game is guaranteed to end.

What are we basing this on?

this

So therefore. Since unless we have a chieftan claim. We know it’s an Effigy/Viceroy game. The demon is a Retrogradus. Therefore we have enough time to kill them both and we win unless I’m brain dead and missed something

any of this confirmed?

The only way the game won’t end, is because we have a chieftan and an eclipse who fucked with Cloneds info

I know I’m good. PKR is saying I’m evil therefore he is probably poisoned by the viceroy. Therefore we know cloned is getting good info. As we know there’s a retrogradus in game. So therefore if there is no chieftan we know that one of Insanity or Whysper is the demon

The other possible worlds are I’m evil and a viceroy poisoned Clonedcheese, or PKR is the effigy and the viceroy poisoned Clonedcheese.

If light is town, then we either have an effigy or a Chieftan

If light is a viceroy, who could not have poisoned Cloned as he was dead. He could have poisoned PKR.

(I’m basically just brainstorming now)

Feel free to bring up any concerns

If light is any other minion,

He cannot be the Effigy unless there is any outsider who is hiding, however there could be a chieftan and an effigy so there being two outsiders does not disprove Light

If light is the Eclipse, Then we know that he could not have tampered with Cloneds info unless the viceroy poisoned him

If light is the secondhand, then that doesn’t affect much, as we know there’s probably a viceroy in play.