please lock moderator
So basically it overcomplicates trials for no forseeable benefit other than anonymous accusations, which harsm BD more than it helps, and generally overcomplicates everything for no forseeable reason.
Nope.
1 Like
So, you need Endgame when Prince and Sherrif/Paladin are usually dead, yourself not to be dead, and even then there is still going to be one non-confirmed on the Jury, and thus thatās useless.
That dosenāt mean it dosenāt stupidly overcomplicate trials.
Oh great. 4 roles need to be alive in endgame, at which point you donāt even need the role because BD will almost certainly win.
WHY IS THIS BETTER? It makes Trials drag on and not everyone can get questions in. The whole point of trials is that itās meant to be easy for people to hijack them.
Itās the whole point of the game. You canāt cancel out the point of a game twice, Unseen or not.
It removes all the skill from trials.
the judge makes it hard for unseen to hijack
disagreed. any player can get a voice by becoming prosecutor.
also, taking the ability from unseen to take over trials is useful, even if it ātakes the skill out of trials.ā
lastly, if an unseen does become juror, you can veto.
the trial drags on, but it is the only day. I donāt think it would be longer than a normal day.
And only one person can do that. Sorry, you need to sit out, you werenāt elected! WATCH EVERYONE PLAY THE GAME FOR YOU.
I meant that the whole point of the game is deception, and hijacking wagons to force mislynches. Making a role just to counter this is dumb.
And finally, you donāt have to THINK that much to use the role. Sherrif has an Unseen but not lynched?
BAM TRIAL LYNCH THEM REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
It takes the skill out of trials in a game of skill.
1 Like
if 16 players alive:
1 of them is a defendant.
5 are jurors.
1 is a judge.
there will be prosecutor, but anyone can try to be the prosecutor.
everyone can talk to jurors during deliberation.
5+1+1 = 7/16
Oh lookie here
You had to explain the mechanic to me, it didnāt come intuitively.
Itās overcomplicated, and we donāt want that!
1 Like
there can still be hijacking. An unseen can become prosecutor when there is an unseen on trial and be really unconvincing.
an unseen that previously made themselves trusted can become a juror.
anyone can speak to jurors and give false information.
plenty of opportunities to hi-jack
just because it is harder for unseen to hijack doesnāt make it take the skill out; it adds difficulty for them, thatās it.
Listen:
Itās ability is too situational! Itās ability is too overcomplicated!
Itās ability takes away chances to deceive in a game of deception.
How many times have you had to say āIfā to explain how the Unseen could hijack the trial?
See! The more 'ifās the worse a class is.
being situational is bad for BD.
taking away chances to deceive is good for BD>
which is it? it canāt be both over powered and under powered at the same time.
Itās swingy.
Thatās what I mean. Itās either useless or itās overpowered.
Do you understand that this is bad?
the more ifs, the more replay ability.
the actual mechanics donāt have that many ifs. The strategy does. ALL CLASSES HAVE āIFSā IN STRATEGY.