ok eph asked for my thoughts outside of
i’m not ordering this for a few reasons but we’ll get there
as i’m extremely lazy and want to play vidya i will proceed to quote posts that accurately describe my thoughts regarding slots. if theres anything someone wants me to expand on let me know ig. whatever
i feel like a shitty person for not putting as much effort into this d1 as i know i can lol
Wazza/Trochi
Chloe:
i got v-vibes from his trochi shit but i considered it kinda angley and didnt wanna comment
but since its been commented on
I take back what i said about being whelmed by TL
he seems comfy, which i find to be >rand v from him
this gives me “sulit and i are talking about smashball” vibes
tldr i wanna v read it
Chloe:
he thinks trochi v but its because he’s a sucker for AtE. He says theyve been pretty transparent about why theyre going to be inactive and hes not going to be focusing on them until theyre back and not in a bad state irl
i think you’re >rand v because of how you talk as if you have no clue (and dont care about) whats happening. also your posts about how you’re interacting with trochi felt pure. you could admittedly be doing a lot more, and my reasons to townread you are pretty flimsy, but they exist. this lower in confidence with every passing hour
Chloe:
i think they AtE’d in g8 but not excessively
also
i wear the pants in this hydra
he also called all of you nerds for shutting down his ate-read
AtE read retracted
Marl also left me with a read on Trochi that boils down to the fact that he thinks they could have TMI because of how they interacted with min in regards to min’s Eli defense (?) - he sucks at wording but i think thats what he means
They apparently also aren’t following through on their “i promise i’ll be townie later” oath that they made at SoD
Vulgard/Nightingale
Chloe:
i dont think vul is VILLAGER
hes more of villager - which is arguably >rand w
i dont want him dead this second
i admittedly could be being pocketed by his lovability
Chloe:
I think Vul is more likely to be a villager than a wolf.
If I ignore meta and focus on this as if vul is… not vul, he is in an absolutely godawful position as a wolf, and he isn’t even really attempting to climb out of it. He’s admitted he’s a likely elim. He isn’t trying to strongarm anything else. He’s posting (fmpov) naturally, as i could see myself saying nearly everything he’s saying in his position. The only real people defending him are myself and kat, and we both have shitty weak reasonings, and, unless kat is a wolf and about to drop the biggest shield of their life, they just arent set up to win.
However
But regardless of how i feel about Vul
Marl was originally scumreading the slot for acting differently to a game they played together and not being high energy
Random votes on people who she townreads
So whatever
Weh
Weh!
There’s still a portion of my brain that thinks Vul is just a villager trying something new, but the amount of evidence pointing to him being a wolf is overwhelming, as well as the fact that night is apparently borderline-openwolfing
Marshal/Blizer
Chloe:
Also marl is entirely convinced that blizer is a villager and it makes my brain do about 500 somersaults wondering what the hell im missing from marshal
And maybe a lot of my marshal read is omgus
I’ll admit think hes been fairly villagery lately with his position leading the thread and his seemingly transparent thought process
Not outside of wolfrange but still
I’ll comeb ack to tjis later i needa do morrrning things
Chloe:
He’s
he’s done this before as a wolf for sure, and i wouldnt be completely surprised if he ended up being a w, if we’re wrong on multiple yeets that he leads
but as of rn i think hes >rand V as his mindset and thought process are laid out pretty transparently in the thread
Aside from Marshal, Blizer seems to be Marl’s strongest (?) townread, from the wording he’s been using. They’re apparently melding on so much, and many trivial things, that he finds it hard to fake
Blizer is also leading and has transparent thoughts, and is ticking all the boxes Marl has in his brain to find a villager
YBW/Eli
Chloe:
i think that
from what marl has told me, and from what i’ve seen of YBW (admittedly i havent read his recent posts yet) i think the slot has wolf potential.
i remember marshal saying that “nobody can read eli, lets be real”
still
Chloe:
his earlier posts felt TWTBAW
so bad and hedgy that they wrapped around to being townie
will read his latest posts soon but theyre long and i’d like to catch-up while realtiming ayaya
maybe hes being townie! will see
Chloe:
im strongly against yeeting them d1
i think eli will unfreeze if he gets more content to absorb and a 12h break from thread - regardless of alignment
im fairly confident in my ability to read eli after jojofm
ja?
Chloe:
without commenting on every single thing in the YBW post i can say that my gut goes “this is a villager,” and his thought process aligns pretty solidly with previous v games.
even if i ignore meta i think he’s doing a decent job of contributing and being transparent (or emulating how a villager would act) for a newbie, which is enough for me to not want to yeet him d1
i actually think this slot comes down to eli moreso because i feel more confident in my ability to read him over YBW
i will say that if this solvey/pure behavior doesn’t continue into d2, and if eli is consistently frozen and/or uncomfortable, my mind will probably change regarding their status as a no-yeet
TL/Kyo
Chloe:
uhhhh
can someone tell me why they think TL v or w if anyone here has a strong read on him
i’m trying to sort him in my head rn and half of it is going “hes acting like he did in neighborhood, therefore town”
im trying to ignore the kyo half because i have no clue how to read kyo, and marl doesn’t really know either and said that kyo flaked recently, so im going to focus on TL since i can absorb the content
will probably iso him after catch-up
but i’d like discussion on the slot because it feels almost ignored
I read TL’s reads, and
I don’t have a lot to say on the post, which feels shitty because he obviously put effort into it
I think his comfort-level is slightly >rand V, and i just
Eph/Manti
Chloe:
continuing my catch up rn (albeit slowly)
i’ve been subconsciously avoiding reading eph because theyre the one person i dont fuckin know in this thread
im leaning v atm, but it aint strong, because i have no real meta crutch, and from my understanding they’re a good wolf
if anyone has experience with them i’d like to know if they’re in their wolfrange
i think the devils-advocate attidude and trying to get thread to focus on things outside of the main topic is a good look
just kinda
that being said i have no clue what manti is doing in thread A because marl has been kinda avoiding the slot because he cant read manti
we suck
I’d like to flesh this one out a bit more as the day continues
i dont know much about eph in regards to meta so i have to actually try to read them
GGhana/Min
Chloe:
what is this sequence
you think TL could be a wolf trying to set up MLs, but you think preflipping is bad
do we have different definitions of preflipping or something
also if you think TL could be a wolf who is setting up MLs by having TMI on me (which, i will say i can see it as possible) then you think im town?
idgi
i think its dumb and almost wraps around to being townie
Marshal:
alright, i’m going to present a v-case on GGhana.
A lot of it stems from his play in catgirl jester nightless, he was Nyan-Chan in that game and it might be worth a read.
His play here is a lot more bullish than wolf games I’ve seen. He has tonal self-confidence and a degree of stubbornness I find villagery. He stands his ground on petty but still, like, game-related things (not saying his lvl of experience to ephemeral for example).
I think him pushing for specifics of what people talked about in cards is villagery. It showed a lust for content when there was a general lack of it and got into borderline territory to keep pressuring. I thought it was villagery.
I buy the growing chloe tunnel. I thought thread’s reaction to him more or less flubbing an explanation for one of his posts was really weird and warped and something I wouldn’t really expect to happen to a wolf? It’s moreso a “not aligned with any of TL/Ephemeral/vulgard” read, but it’s a point in his favor.
That’s more or less it
Do you see what I see, or where am I going wrong.
I just now realized that i havent actually said exactly why i townread gghana but its basically everything written in this post. Pretend I wrote this and not Marshal
He’s annoying and frustrating in a way that feels genuine, like a villager who was misguided (regarding his take on me) rather than throwing shade and pushing agenda. He has a pretty transparent thought process and feels rather natural and free-flowy
Marl thinks min is v because of how high their wim is, as well as the quality of their posts. Marl sucks for not giving me more on min
Sulit/Katze
[REDACTED]
@Ephemeral you wanted this so here you go
ulgard