The Noble/Apostle ability that listens to every single whisper isn’t good for the health of the game.
It discourages both good and evil from cooperating and making plays.
It’s especially punishing for Neutral Killers and Neutral/Evil kings trying to work with the bad guys.
If I whisper somebody I should be able to do it in confidence. The fact that people can see who and when I whisper should be enough for them to deduce.
Is this really a big problem? It’s only 2 uses and mostly you won’t get any useful info. It would be a problem if there is more roles then 4 that can see whispers.
Make it not usable until n3 like all the other powerful abilities. Cold Steel, Hunter Wolf, Butler Poison.
It’s 3 uses, I’ve received good information every n1 I’ve used it.
It’s not powerfull at all.
In fact I argue that you won’t find the neutral until after D2
Personally I just don’t start whispering until D3 after the nobles have gotten a spy out of their system (particularly apostle)
Even so it’s still didn’t answer to my question. If you’re BD why would you be afraid that Noble would know your claim? I would say it’s benefit because he can actually try to cooperate with you.
It’s not that hard to avoid nobles listening in when they only have 3 uses if you keep that fact in mind
Sorry I should have clarified, It’s not just Nobles. Apostles too.
Also Nobles can get converted.
