Min probabilities: Town > Neut Not-Evil > NE > Wolf
Alright, you do you.
I’m just going with my own thoughts.
In response to your own
Mkay
I’m gonna be busy for the rest of the day
I think Napoleon is just likely town
Not lock, but his posting has been consistently solid
I wish I could quote from mobile but I think he’s firmly within my village range and the only one I can actually firmly say for concrete reasons is a villager
If I die I’d follow him, he has the will and experience to lead.
(I also just remembered conversion exists so obviously be sparing but I want it known that nap is very likely just a villager atm)
(Also conversion exists. Cringe.)
2 Likes
I’m trying to make my posts as digestible as possible for those unfamiliar with general forum mafia play, but if anyone doesn’t get anything in my posts I can explain them
I’d prefer conversion stopping effects on myself and Napoleon
We should absolutely look to deny n1 converts because we want mafia to have as little influence as possible when it comes to king elections.
At the very least we should try to keep trusted solvers out of the hands of the cult or unseen
Im here yes, although I’m pretty confused what to post/talk about. Honestly ill prob get more active as i figure out how this all works so sorry in advance for me being a bit passive the first cycle or two.
In that case I’d think Marl should be added to the list.
Along with some others in game should they prove themselves.
We should have a list sorted a while before EoD for conversion stopping effects. Let’s aim for 1-2 hours early.
Unless all conversion stopping things are night time stuff.
Then we can wait even closer to the time.
Marshal is referring to the cult as mafia, they accidentally revealed the true allignment gg we found them
I’m very wary of ATNoName
He isn’t really giving anything in the form of reasoning when I know he can
He’s throwing out takes left and right and even changing them but giving exactly 0 insight into why he has them in a game where that insight is extremely important
1 Like
Very well.
I’m not saying they should be conversion protected or anything.
I’m just saying I personally can see town doing this more often than scum.
Especially in this game.
It’s literally just wifoming your reads
Each player should be evaluated with reasoning. “TWTBAW” itself is just leveling yourself away from a read.
If you want to go into the realm of “X player would not do this or care this little as wolf” that’s fine
But TWTBAW (too wolfy to be a wolf for our newer players, basically the idea that someone is acting so much like a mafia member that it loops around to being villagery) is level 1 reads that serve to help nobody
I think scum have much more reason to flood the thread with takes and not have to back them up
I’m not gonna stake it all on this read
But it’s bad and I think he knows it
1 Like
Either way I genuinely have to go now
But just
Please make concrete reasons for reads, those of you who know how to, and those who don’t please try
D1 is more important than you think, n1 actions shape the game and not a ton is going on.
Try to give what substance you can
Quick question, in this are we allowed to say our role outright?