ok i should probably ellaborate: when there are reasons to townread aelin and thats the only reasons to not do so it can be pushed aside and explained via bad townplay.
i know i am displaying a certain level of confidence on my reads but I generally get by in my games by making sure my townreads actually stay alive and tricking scum into killing into my PoE
i come from a site that generally has a higher level of mafia play due to vast experience - its an expected reaction to the depth of the reads i have and how people view them.
I cant prove someone’s towniness but i can show someone’s scumminess
So its on you
Quote any post - litterally any - that marshal has scumtold, that i havent addressed already.
Preferably the first post that made you think marshal scum.
like sure it could be shitty town play but i find it way more likely that aelin just isn’t town 
they’ve done similar before
i.e short fuse game, they shot after nightmage did even tho their yolo shot hit town
it doesn’t make sense for town (aelin) to shoot there, it’s just not something that would come from a cautious person who rolled town
yes it could just be unbelievably shitty judgement, but it’s more than likely aelin is just mafia trying to get the extra town flip instead of aelin being town and deciding whats the worse that could happen
same logic applies
yes aelin could be town that just tunnled eli to oblivion
but (as one having been tunneled by aelin) this push is scummy because it doesn’t really have any reasoning behind it
their confidence doubles with little reasoning and after Eli flips town they don’t have any reaction that would say “well i guess i was wrong, oof”
they shift the blame on eli for being scummy despite not even having reason behind their push
so like, if aelin has done anything towny enough to offset this I’d be glad to hear it but i don’t think they have
1 Like
^^ these are 2 strings of posts that are strong reasons why Aelin is town
these are incredibly hard thought processes to fake as scum.
this is how I find town typically.
| Player | Voted by | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Aelin | clonedcheese, Marshal, sulit | 3/8 |
| PokemonKidRyan | Intensify, eevee | 2/8 |
| NetherNitro | Wazza, ATNoName | 2/8 |
| Marshal | DkKoba | 1/8 |
| Wazza | NetherNitro | 1/8 |
| sulit | PokemonKidRyan | 1/8 |
| clonedcheese | Esooa | 1/8 |
| Not voting | Universal, SkyRED, Aelin, Amelia | 4 |
Ping me for errors. Pinging me for votes is cool, too.