Orangevitational - Aliens Win!

[Eavesdropper]

Ok, valid point.

[Officer]

@Teleporter

I think I’m villareading it a little, actually? I might be drinking the wine, but the question I’m asking myself is this. If you’re the wolf vig in a game where only two of you need to die for villagers to win the game, would you intentionally invite that much negative attention onto your slot?

If I rand wolf vig/Security in this game (I guess if I rand Security at all, no matter what my alignment is), I’m being extremely collaborative and would offer to use the kill as a second town execution (which I think is the best way to play the role). Again, I could be drinking too much wine or imposing on other people how I’d use the role, but I’d imagine a wolf vig would try to get town points or lie low by being very cooperative about their shot.

Anyone else seeing where I’m coming from?

Yeah. I also think they may have been playing it up for RP. I don’t wolfread them, but hope if they are town they will be cooperative

[Eavesdropper]

What’s your current opinion of Facilitator, then? Anything new? How does the slot compare to other slots, since I assume some are townier and some are scummier.

[Eavesdropper]

@Security

This is why you’re still a student and have a C minus in math.

Ok it’s just RPing I guess lol.
Hope he doesn’t shoot a towncore member richt away, whenever we actually have them, until there’s at least some discussion over it.

[Officer]

@Teleporter

@Eavesdropper

Ehhhh

At the point where I am in backreading, I currently find that Cryo is kinda wolfy but made one post so far that I think was towny, Student is just a null for me, Trap is somewhat towny, Scientist is a null because I don’t think i paid enough attention yet to their posts, and Teleporter is also null.

Still catching up, I’m not done yet.

What point in the thread were you at when you made this post? Asking for reasons.

@Cryogenics

I haven’t seen anyone talk about Officer that much, so here’s my thoughts on the slot. I feel like their opening was pretty much ignored, and I can see why, but their opening has such a big contrast between their other posts that I’m kind of concerned there - I know a couple wolves who are good wolves once they are getting rolling but they struggle in the opening posts, and I can see that being the case with Officer.

This is a good observation. I think Student said that they were going to reread Officer. I’ll probably do the same once I settle into my backreading phase. One post of there’s that kinda pinged me was this:

@Officer

Oh god why did an egotistical hero shooter have to rand vig

Be a team player please

Because it feels like a post you make when you’re trying to figure out what villager you would post rather than it being an organic thought? Not sure if anyone else got the same poor gut feeling I did.

No I was legit frustrated at their posts. Calmed down after they said they were exaggerating for RP.

[Officer]

I particularly took offense at their criticism of having several townreads early, because that’s a way I like to play and works fairly well in my experience

[Eavesdropper]

@Trapsetter

As an aside I think eavesdropper’s reaction to being told to read the thread being “eh, fine” is pretty bad but I care more about the content they produce than this little tidbit

I don’t really have a problem backreading 400 posts, did you expect me to complain more?

[Eavesdropper]

@Cryogenics

Can you explain more about your student read. Student feels as though they have enough content to get a read on them.

Did I answer this yet? I’ve finished catching up and I think Student is probably town, partly due to wagonomics but also because their posting improved throughout the day so far. some of their posts really looked like they were trying to solve other players based on what was being said or which reads were being given, and they were also solving around the reads on their own slot rather than just accepting them.

[Officer]

@Teleporter

/unvote
/vote Officer

Kinda lightly skimmed their ISO and they haven’t really shown much in the way of towntells besides the MU article thing.

Feeling I’m getting from reading their posts is that they’re kinda going with the flow as opposed to trying to make something happen.

I prefer to go with the flow if I don’t feel super strongly about a read. I do however still feel good voting for Faci as they have still not been remotely villagery while almost everyone else has.

[Teleporter]

Think I’m good with these people for now:

Cryogenics
Trapsetter
Surv
Student

Security is weird because I don’t actively think they’re a wolf, but I would like them to be a little more cooperative when it comes to playing the game.

Eavesdropper has made solid posts when catching up, but kind of want them to finish catching up and provide a general summation on where they’re at.

Fine with pressuring these slots today:

Officier
Scientist
Communications
Facilitator
Coroner

SBPC, BCWWE. It never fails!

[Officer]

@Eavesdropper

@Teleporter

I guess my natural follow up to this question would be - who do you think the wolves who were parroting the scumread on me are? I was being scumread by a lot of people who I think are town now, which is why I’m asking.

And OK. Reason why I was asking was that I found it hard to believe that you had a null read on me when I was pretty much the central focus of the game back then. Thought you would have some sort of read on me, whether good or bad, by then.

I honestly did not keep track of exactly which players scumread you I think the wagon was started by town, though, and the difference is how fast people jumped to clear you or consider that you might not be scum, versus players who really gave no reevaluation of you.

And yeah I specifically put you as null because of the fact that something told me you were town, probably mostly wagonomics, but I couldn’t find much to back it up until somewhere after that post. And you still aren’t my top townread so lol.

I can’t follow what this says and I’m not sure if that’s towny or what

[Student]

Where I’m at currently

Towncore: Surveillance, Trapsetter
Villagers: Cryogenics, Teleporter, Communications
Null: Eavesdropper, Coroner, Officer
Wolfy: Scientist, Security, Facilitator

Let’s hope Security doesn’t OMGUS shoot me T_T

[Officer]

I was independently coming to townreading you just from your posting but around the same time others said you were likely bait so it was kind of half sheeping as well.

Don’t care about being called out for hedging, it’s town indicative if anything.

[Student]

@Officer

I was independently coming to townreading you just from your posting

Which posts in particular?

@Officer

Don’t care about being called out for hedging, it’s town indicative if anything.

That-
uh
What

Summary

It’s probably villagery for officer to outright say this even though it’s like objectively incorrect

[Officer]

@Eavesdropper

What’s your current opinion of Facilitator, then? Anything new? How does the slot compare to other slots, since I assume some are townier and some are scummier.

I think only exactly Coroner has less going for them than Faceless rn.

I do hope Fusilli returns

[Eavesdropper]

@Trapsetter

Towncore:

Trapsetter
Student
Surveillance
Communications

Fringe Towncore (mostly just in consideration for the above tier):

Officer
Cryogenics
Teleporter (votes thing is honestly probably just from town but im too annoyed to rlly go beyond that)

Everyone else:

Scientists
Coroner
Eavesdropper
facilitator
Security

Quote is irrelevant; it’s just that I’m on mobile and don’t want to miss any names lol.

Townread:
Trapsetter
Cryogenics
Student

Townlean:
Teleporter
Surveillance

Null:
Communications (because I think I mixed them up with someone else and now idk where to place them)
Security (came in guns blazing and refused to cooperate)
Coroner (hasn’t posted enough yet)

A sack of potatoes:
Officer
Scientist
Facilitator

[Officer]

Don’t remember much from Comms either, I think I felt good about their entry?

[Coroner]

@Teleporter

(honestly them changing it to friggin YES kinda ruined my desire to play through the first case)

It didn’t bother me before, but it certainly does now, thanks

[Eavesdropper]

They haven’t been very memorable and I don’t think that’s a good sign.

[Teleporter]

@Student if you inherit Security’s role after they’ve used their shot, do you get a shot as well?

Should be able to look this up myself but I’m on mobile.