actually, yeah. coroner can also be the sympathizer lying for the wolfteam’s benefit. that’s also an option.
yet another reason why i think we should kill coroner tomorrow regardless of what flip they claim for student. it’s mechanically optimal for us. disproves comm/coroner w/w worlds and comm/coroner w/sympathizer worlds.
2 Likes
saying this honestly really sucks if coroner is just v and would like to actually play the game, but in my defense, the slot’s had one day and a half to be villagery. i’m treating today as half because i don’t see it going much longer if student doesn’t awaken. and even if student does awaken, i don’t see many options other than “student is alien odd night kp.”
Why could eaves have only been even night kp? Am I missing something obvious?
i still lean toward coroner v, but leaving them alive is too dangerous considering they are part of important worlds.
if they were odd night kp, someone other than them would’ve also flipped last night.
in other words, while i think coroner’s v, i don’t believe in that so strongly that i’ll forgo optimal play to defend them.
1 Like
We’ll see, we won’t know what is fully optimal until tomorrow
scientist’s check tonight is also going to be quite important, so i suggest protection on the slot from facilitator or trapsetter. even if the slot’s mafia, that’s something we’ll figure out after we hear their results.
considering security’s almost always town, i’d check them against someone outside of towncore if i were scientist.
1 Like
Yeah, that’s why I was saying we should wait until tomorrow, if we get a red on the parity cop we want coroner around one more day at least
yup, in that case that would be best.
did everyone die? hello?
1 Like
I’m p sure most people are doing morning stuff
I know half the game was waiting for student to check in yesterday and he never did and probably never will
the activity drop is extremely weird after day 1.
1 Like
any insights or are you just accepting a student flip and waiting?
More or less
I’m definitely not unvoting if he doesn’t post, I’m not letting them get away with the cold feet strategy
could just be in antispew tbh. same reason i’m not unvoting either.
Ye, or that. If student is an alien it means cryo is never an alien, could be a sympathizer but not a pack alien ever
if cryo is the sympathizer and student is a wolf, cryo must be kicking themselves rn.
1 Like
but i think cryo’s just town. occam’s razor and stuff.
I feel better compared to yesterday, at least that’s something. Anyway, I read what has happened so far and I can see where people are coming from with regards to student potentially being a wolf in this case. I didn’t think much of the fact that the wolf kill was presumably blocked, but now that I think about it, it does indicate that student could be a wolf here and them not showing up is nagl
I disagree with this take solely because the way they spoke about their role D1. If they were a wolf they would be concerned with being consistent in their reasoning and wouldn’t hammer arbitrary here based off the fact that they said they were worried they would hammer with their role on D1