Orangevitational - Aliens Win!

[Whysper]

VOTECOUNT

Player	Voted by	Votes
Student	Security, Surveillance, Facilitator, Coroner	4/6
Teleporter	Officer	2/6
Not Voting	Trapsetter, Student, Cryogenics, Scientist, Teleporter	5

With 10 players alive, it takes 6 to reach majority.

[Student]

I do not appreciate the fact that people saying Security’s play on both days is likely to come from town when I have explained why it is in fact more likely to be the opposite.

[Teleporter]

I’m gonna spend some time today working on a general gamestate summation post.

No promises on when it’ll be out but I do request that people don’t hammer in the next 24 hours or so.

I’m so confused with this game lmao.

[Surveillance]

so basically if i assume student’s v because his posts are good then we’re just going to wagon facilitator again at this rate.

[Surveillance]

/unvote

to prevent officer from getting any funny ideas.

[Surveillance]

@Cryogenics

How is killing coroner suboptimal before we get the scientist checked? Scientist parity checked security m

m.

[Whysper]

VOTECOUNT

Player	Voted by	Votes
Student	Security, Facilitator, Coroner	3/6
Teleporter	Officer	2/6
Not Voting	Trapsetter, Student, Cryogenics, Scientist, Teleporter, Surveillance	6

With 10 players alive, it takes 6 to reach majority.

[Cryogenics]

I’m going to check what facilitator has done today

[Officer]

@Surveillance

facilitator is still an option, i guess. they could’ve healed and killed eavesdropper, and i would’ve only seen the healing part.

Well, they would have not healed but. Yeah

[Student]

Killing Coroner is probably not suboptimal, since from my PoV it either outright ends the game if they were lying about Communications being town (thus making them both wolves) or it proves Security is either a wolf or scientist/facilitator, both people not paying attention to the game.

[Surveillance]

real answer:

• scientist might want to check coroner
• the n1 might die and we would like to know their alignment for the parity check wouldn’t we

[Surveillance]

@Student

from my PoV it either outright ends the game if they were lying about Communications being town

this is true, i talked about this earlier.

@Student

Security is either a wolf or scientist/facilitator, both people not paying attention to the game.

how does flipping coroner prove that security’s a wolf?

[Teleporter]

I kinda want to see who just sheeped the Student case without adding much critical thought to the wagon.

I don’t want to work in worlds where the game would end soon because IMO they’re not worth considering. I want to plan for the worst-case scenario always. If the game ends randomly, then that’s a pleasant surprise.

[Student]

If I were the N1 attacker, I would have either used my positioning in thread to propose a different jailkeep target or at least come into some day with a plan with my teammate (if the other wolf is still alive). I think it’s pretty unreasonable to assume I would have just sat waiting to be outted like this?

[Student]

From my PoV, Coroner or Security has to be a wolf unless wolves aren’t paying attention and factionaled me.

[Surveillance]

@Student

From my PoV, Coroner or Security has to be a wolf

i don’t really understand, still.

[Officer]

okay. Student is swaying me. Atm I’d like to yeet in Coroner/Tele/Faci

[Student]

@Student

I haven’t finished backreading yet, but from what I gathered Security claims to have shot Eavesdropper, which if he’s telling the truth means scum failed the factional. Scum not succeeding with the factional means either Communications was the wolf who attacks on N1 and Coroner is his teammate who is lying to cover for it, or it means that Security is a wolf who holstered and factionaled Eavesdropper.

Does this explain it?

[Surveillance]

@Student

If I were the N1 attacker, I would have either used my positioning in thread to propose a different jailkeep target or at least come into some day with a plan with my teammate (if the other wolf is still alive). I think it’s pretty unreasonable to assume I would have just sat waiting to be outted like this?

that’s the biggest thing pointing in your favor, i just figured you were probably a wolf by mechanics and ignored that. i’ve been burned on neglecting mechanics completely before.

[Surveillance]

@Student

Does this explain it?

oh, okay, i get it now.