If it is objectively true, why is it a good look for them? Wolves can easily point out things that as you say are “objectively true”.
I also don’t understand why you don’t think Trapsetter would make this post unless he’s a wolf with Teleporter. Why can’t it be W/V?
That’s fair, especially in an anonymous game
Oh right, I remember now. Thank you. I don’t think this post looks that bad though, perhaps it’s indicative of sitting on the sidelines but my gut is telling me that Teleporter’s lack of involvement is probably more of a playstyle thing than anything alignment indicative.
You’re right about that. If you’re a wolf, you’re playing it exactly like you would have to in order to get any utility out of your role.
oh I have something to add to this
I mentioned previously that they felt as though they were playing on an armchair (not sure exact phrase I used) and that was not a townie thing to do
but later on it felt like they got a more expensive arm chair in their analysis and i felt as though their explanations felt more natural
not sure how helpful this “insight” is but
No, I see what you mean. Their posting has become more natural as the game progressed, particularly with their response to being accused of trying to derpclear.
Security seems motivated to give themselves an unrestricted shot with no need of explanation but also really hasn’t explained how planning the shot hurts their chances of shooting a wolf at all.
“Wolves can stop the shot”… no, they can’t, not without outting themselves and their partner in the process, thanks to the eavesdropper existing.
There’s no reason to at least publicly say your shot so that it can be planned around and no reason not to get input from others so they can plan their actions around it.
Seems like they’re trying to go for a “shoot first, say sorry later” scenario. I dont buy it personally.
As an aside I think eavesdropper’s reaction to being told to read the thread being “eh, fine” is pretty bad but I care more about the content they produce than this little tidbit
This is what I am trying to say. They are playing it how they would need to as a wolf in order to use their role to shoot a villager without being killed for it.
Can’t tell if i adore or hate cryo putting ham-fisted analogies into reads that can realistically be explained just using words.
my next one will be a ham sandwich analogy
It’s like a girrafe, who is trying to get food from a tree, but waves their neck around to get the food in a more extravagant way just to attract the female girrafes.
#deep
That’s a joke btw
these images just come up in my brain whenever I read posts
Back and reading up.
Should be around for the next couple of hours, then I’ll be gone from the thread until tonight.
Ehhhh
At the point where I am in backreading, I currently find that Cryo is kinda wolfy but made one post so far that I think was towny, Student is just a null for me, Trap is somewhat towny, Scientist is a null because I don’t think i paid enough attention yet to their posts, and Teleporter is also null.
Still catching up, I’m not done yet.
Not sure whether I like this or not
Can you explain more about your student read. Student feels as though they have enough content to get a read on them.
Maybe this is minor but I think this post looks good for Surveillance.
I’m not there yet, getting there though