EDIT: Rephrasing this start part: Unless you can find a way to balance whispers so that you have them used but not abused, remove whispers altogether.
This just sets the game back to the various metas that, as I said, prevented a lot of peoples actual participation in the game. We removed the Mystics private whispers because it was abused and turned the game into a single player game. Birds was added in the first place to try and stop WKM. And now you’re going backwards. And I’m tired of seeing this game go backwards instead of forward. We’re going back to a game that is a wall of pink text with the king voting someone up with no context and just saying “exe”.
You can’t really refuse to participate in it either, as inevitably it becomes the norm and if you refuse you are upped and exed. If enough people do manage to refuse and maintain a balance then good for them but we’ve seen from the past that this doesn’t happen.
Though as I phrased it on Discord:
Can this game never actually go forward and do new things, rather than repeating the mistakes of the past or rehashing the same old stuff?
Edited this a lot due to bad phrasing and being more aggressive than intended.