Pokèmon 9er - Informed Spec Chat

[Silviu200530]

Did kiro reveal himself as a strategy?

[Silviu200530]

[SFM] Newbie-Friendly Pokèmon 9er - Day 3 (5/9)

It’s funny, I get the feeling that Gorta is stalling for time and Kiro is encouraging a hammer.

[clonedcheese]

@WindwardAway

Kiro, you did a good job of falsely leading us to townread you. It was a good play, at the risk of Cloned flipping town during the night. Your behavior as scum is more or less the same as your behavior as town, so I’ll keep that in mind for future reference.

Gorta, you did a good job misleading us as well. Ultimately, it’s the lack of not only interacting with but also discussing Kiro’s place on your readlist that gives you away. You made decently convincing pushes and covered for your mistakes by appealing to us as having made dumb choices.

Worse, you improved a lot from the beginning of the game by sharing your thoughts. I scumread you for a long time because you were keeping most of your thoughts private besides your readlist when asked, and because you were sheeping on the votes, but you’re one of the few (or maybe the only one) who had a correct readlist much earlier in the game. Your reasoning makes plenty of sense, so don’t be afraid to speak up next time.

Arctic, you had a really solid strategy by working from the bottom up and essentially considering all of us guilty until proven innocent. It gave you reasons to pick at people’s statements and actions to find reasons to read them as scum, and when you didn’t find indications of wolfiness, you moved them toward a townread. If you ever do that as wolf, we’d probably lose lol. You were vocal the whole game, so it was easy to follow your train of thought.

Cloned, thanks for giving your reads and your strategies. I was really starting to wonder if I should be suspecting you or Kiro more, or if both of you were possibly town, but it worked out in the end. Your alignment cop fakeclaim was a nice strategy that was likely meant to bait me, but ended up baiting Kiro instead, and I got inspired to bait Kiro with a fake tracking claim from that.

Appel, sorry for doubting you and believing Gorta’s push on you simply because he claimed you were within your wolfrange and because you finally snapped at him before getting mislynched. You also had what I thought was a very objective analysis on everyone, similar to what I thought Arctic was doing; I just didn’t know how to read it anymore after Gorta started hard pushing.

Min and Silviu, sorry you guys died so early and sorry for scumreading both of you (especially Silviu). D1 didn’t give me much information to work with, and at least now I have a slightly clearer idea of how you both play as town.

GG, I think I’ve said all the important stuff I wanted to say before getting sniped. xD Thanks for making my first FM game a lot of fun!

holy fuck Wind I love you

[clonedcheese]

@WindwardAway

I also strongly trust what Cloned said about lynching you if Appel flipped town. Cloned has more experience so if he thought that one of you flipping town meant the other was wolf, then he’s likely correct.

Wind why

[min]

Wind is so poggers

[Silviu200530]

[SFM] Newbie-Friendly Pokèmon 9er - Day 3 (5/9)

Anyway, hey town, there’s your answer. Once we lynch Kiro, if he flips rolecop, Gorta is scum for TMI.

I bet gorta will say “hey town” seems wolfy

[Silviu200530]

Gorta did well tho

[Silviu200530]

I thought that both kiro and gorta are acting as their normal self, oops

[clonedcheese]

They are
kiro’s… surprisingly good at scum
I thought they would be similar to surge and be awfully obvious

gorta’s not much different lol

[Appelsiini]

I’m so proud of Wind. I want to give her headpats when the game ends~

[Silviu200530]

Kiro still seems to be seth’s sidekick. But his wins on the social debates they played really shows, I think.

[clonedcheese]

I feel like to a degree he used his seth-y-ness to his advantage here?

His pushing on me was reminiscent on Seth and I pretty much cleared Kiro until i died

[GGhana]

wind goat

[min]

Based af tbh

[Silviu200530]

They should make a movie out of this

[clonedcheese]

hi windward

thanks so much lol

[WindwardAway]

He did
But he used it to his advantage as town as well, so he clearly figured it would work both ways. It was a smart move on his part; only the PR scuffle screwed him over.

[WindwardAway]

Also Gorta with his scumslip of the century lol

From what I read, he kind of just does dumb voting in every game regardless of alignment? So I really couldn’t tell until he started scumslipping left and right.

[WindwardAway]

Anyway, it looks like ggs soon. I kind of doubt Gorta could possibly redeem himself and convince Worse to vote Arctic out at this point; he was doing OK with his excuses until D3 and he’s out of options now lol. Plus Worse actually correctly read the scum early on (along with Appel, and not sure if there was someone else?) so I guess as soon as Gorta writes his last excuse, they’re gonna hammer.