For me, the biggest problem with reaper is what happens when he get attacked.
The attacker doesn’t get any message and the reaper just don’t die.
I think the attacker should get a message “your target was immune”, so the reaper will be able to claim night immune classes like merc / alch / inq /guarded by king.
Right now, every attacker knows that the reaper is 100% reaper.
No. The message you get for hitting reaper is the same as if you hit a phys target which is far more likely than being guarded by king. And claiming Alch in response to that will get you killed anyway.
All the night immune classes have claim problems:
-merc: no one can say they are your target
-alchemist: you can’t heal to prove, and might get executed anyways
-guarded by king: king can just say he didn’t
-merc: no one can say they are your target
In my experience, if you revealed to them D1, people will generally believe it (evils are unlikely to want to fake being a merc with a specific target D1, since it puts them in danger of getting called out when their “target” dies and they’re unable to offer a contract to anyone.)
