Return Of The Darkness Upick - Game Over - well that happened i guess

[sulit]

My main problem with night is that all of their reads don’t actually have conclusion

In that either they say their reasoning is too weak or they say “this is scummy, but this is towny, so I don’t know”

[Chloe]

i liked her approach to your slot and i said as much earlier, yeah

everything after that just feels extremely slimy to me but

can be explained by the idea that’s she’s forcing herself to stay in Thread when she does not want to be.

this is fair
your thoughts lowered the confidence on my scumread but i still dont really
townread
them
i want more from 'em

[katze]

is this wolfy or a low confidence villager

[sulit]

It feels like they’re not trying to solve actual alignments so wolfy

I’d have to go back and reread the specific posts to be sure tho

[Mistyx]

We understand.

We hold to our own opinions regarding Night despite this.

[sulit]

@Nightingale

Min feels good in thread tonewise but not really concrete or definitive

@Nightingale

liked your post about being hyper and it feels relateable to my experiences as a villager
I havent wolfed (discounting ongoing games) since what
January
so idk how fakeable this stuff is nowadays

@Nightingale

don’t really get the windward vote
not contesting it and was tempted to pile on saying “imitation is a form of flattery.”
but still don’t really get it

@Nightingale

whatever
not interested in pushing wind for now

@Nightingale

I feel like this is more like a type of post you would make as wolf
not like you’re out of your village range by any means
but

@Nightingale

the one thing I vaguely liked about wind is that they didn’t handle pressure stiffly
I see where youre coming from but idk
not very confident about it

@Nightingale

Chloe also could be a wolf but w/e
cross that bridge once they actually do wolfy stuff or not cross it if they do villagery stuff

@Nightingale

zone is like
whatever
stuff could go either way for me rn

@Nightingale

I don’t see Arctic as particularly villagery anyways
although I don’t think they’re wolfy either

unlike Zone who has tonal/mindset stuff going in both directions for them

@Nightingale

this amount of text about that one post is probably entirely unwarranted and all hypothetical anyways

@Nightingale

I endorse this vote for now but not voting because there’s a few people I’d want to vote at around this confidence level
which is admittedly pretty low
but

@Nightingale

they have some posts that I see how other people think they are wolfy
I personally don’t think they’re wolfy
and they aren’t freezing up and/or being stiff or mechanical in response to pressure imo
so like, I wouldn’t push there, but that’s sort of a whotever read

@Nightingale

i was going to say this is villagery but its probably nai

[TrustworthyLiberal]

Quotes.
Do you think these support your thought or change it in anyway?

[sulit]

It feels more like village under confidence than agenda

But I feel like a villager would be more proactive to like, actually read people

I don’t know night very well tho

[sulit]

They don’t attempt to follow up on anything

[TrustworthyLiberal]

Then you should watch then closer into tomorrow rather then make a hasty decision

[Arctic]

@TrustworthyLiberal

And here I am at post 482 looked up and hated that I worte so much why I hate this am gonna go take pain killers and start again in a bit

what

[TrustworthyLiberal]

Whatsvth questio?

[Arctic]

what’s wrong with the post

[TrustworthyLiberal]

Thats the post I read up to.
Not that I disliked it that I hated how much I typed

[Mistyx]

We strongly Trust Nightingale and sulit thus far. Having read into both of their contributions, we have gotten strong feelings that their thoughts towards the Game have been genuine.

We extend our Trust more weakly to Chloe, min, EliThePsycho, katze, and TrustworthyLiberal. The former two have been posting well and often, while Eli’s motivation seems favorable. We are inclined to believe katze’s Claim for the time being, due to how she handled it. Trustworthy’s comfort in Thread seems to be positively indicative as well.

We have had no feelings towards Apprentice, an_gorta_pratai, SirDerpsALot, or ArcticXI. While the former two are due to lack of Activity, we are slightly concern about the lack of impressions that the latter two left on us, though we are willing to believe that it is due to their Playstyles not meshing well with us.

We are completely unsure how to view Zone, and have not yet attempted to do so.

We were expecting to see more from both Marluxion and Marshal, and are inclined to distrust both until we see something to make us feel confident in Trusting them.

We believe that both WindwardAway and Jane have been actively Suspicious. Windward has been awkward in Thread constantly, and has had poor reactions to pressure, as well as a take on Gorta that we felt did not fit in the flow of how the Thread viewed him. We also believe Jane’s Entrance interacting with the Host but none of the players was suspicious, and they have done nothing to convince us otherwise.

[Arctic]

oh ok i’m stupid

[TrustworthyLiberal]

Naw I read back I see how you got to that conclusion.

I just yeah lol

[sulit]

/vote wind

[TrustworthyLiberal]

[Arctic]

@min

I meant as in the fact that you literally have given thoughts and empty headed observations thathavent gone towards reads

ok
give examples

@min

Saying stuff like “well hey this post is useless” and then doing literally nothing with it and also being hypocritical and making a useless post later is just wolfy in my opinion

you have only given an example of this after you voted me
plus is it really necessary to elaborate on the meaning of a post being useless? it’s indicative of a wolf trying to appear like they’re doing something through hyperposting and hedge without actually doing anything
i assumed this much was obvious