my main concern with the eli thing was the possibility that he’s forcing the narrative rather than coming to it naturally
like when he says eli was paranoid with 2 votes on him
it feels like a bit of a stretch
@Aelin would probably be useful to get a mod to lock the thread next time, there’s always the risk of accidentally replying there with this neighbourhood chat. I’m trying to keep it in mind when gathering a lot of quotes, but just in case.
Hippo's progression on Chloe
Yeah, it’s not really explained. I didn’t like it because I townread Chloe at the time, I don’t like how they later left their vote on Eli instead of CRich though. It’s not towny, but it’s hard to form conclusions when they haven’t explained it nor discussed their slot with other people - though they did offer to do that with Cloned, which is a better look.
That might be the case. Those were early reads, so I’m willing to give him a pass, but he didn’t really talk about Eli after that and didn’t advocate for a CFD either.
There wasn’t a whole lot of content after the posts I quoted apart from just pushing Chloe/CRich, and it doesn’t sit right with me that he never commented on others’ opinions despite there being a lot of discussion around the slot. There are things that look good, but it might just be because the problems are with things he isn’t doing which are obviously harder to recognize.
I’d probably put them at nullzone as of now, and inquire more during the day.
if you start making the post in this group chat then it will give you a prompt if you accidentally try to send it in the main thread
oh yeah
don’t you think it’s a bit weird how he kind of just stopped talking about eli
it’d suggest that hippo was being opportunistic with the marl/chloe thunderdome and just put his scumread on eli aside
ok wtf i somehow missed this
i better say this now then
i came up with a big brain idea that if you’re on the risk of dying tomorrow, claim doctor
you’ll be attacked at night (because scum have no way of failing the kill on the doctor) and i can save you
ISOing Marl. I don’t really understand why people keep seeing Eli’s vote as being opportunistic when it’s blatantly NAI annoyance. The Marshal/Eli W/W read that followed was also ???
I think their progression on Chloe is pretty good, though.
The first 2 posts were ~4 hours apart. I’m ignoring the thunderdome that followed since it was obviously due to Marl being angry with me
I don’t like the way the their read on Marshal disappeared just because Eli was being sassy, and they never commented on her again as far as I know. The push on Derps looks extremely town-motivated, however. I feel like if Marl really was a wolf, they wouldn’t have come up with a “PR or wolf” read on Derps and pushed him with such confidence based on that.
I was actually thinking about the exact same thing. That’s the best way to go about it even if we’re not in danger of dying and ever have to claim, because it’ll confuse the scumteam and possibly ruin their plans at some point.
1 Like
I’ll try to be towny enough to the point where Vul and others pushing me will leave me alone, and where I won’t get vigged by Mist if she lives. If I can only accomplish the former, I’m straight up adding Mist to this chat so we can all discuss our night actions together.
yeah this is the strongest point in his favour imo
it’s just so random and i don’t think he’d come up with that as a wolf
especially since it comes with the risk of knowingly pushing someone who he thinks could be a PR
Mist will most likely stay alive until you die. Honestly, I think it’d be good if Mist were to announce she was going to shoot me tomorrow or after that: wolves would definitely not roleblock her, and you can both save your abilities and give her a chance to find a wolf to shoot.
actually yeah that’d be perfect
the problem is i definitely think one of me or mist are dying tonight
it’s either that or min/marshal dies
i don’t think min is enough of a threat for wolves to kill right now and i don’t think marshal is as consensus town as i am
so i really do think me or mist dies
Ah, I see. That’s a bit problematic.
The only thing I’m scared of is Mist shooting me tonight. It’s apparently a 1-shot vig, so I guess there is no perfect-world scenario when it comes to night plans…
…Unless we find the tracker?
worst case scenario is if you get vigged and i get nightkilled
it’s not impossible but pretty unlikely i think
depends how much mist identifies with vulgard’s scumread of you
I’m going to take a break for now
I still have to ISO PKR, Wazza, Atlas, lol and Marshal. Maybe take a look at Chloe/CRich’s reads and ISO Vul & Min if I have time.
I don’t know about if we’re in a full agreement yet about the strength of some of these, but here’s mine
Eli / Mist
Min / Vulgard
Marl / Cloned / Derps
Marshal / Ami / Everyone I haven’t read yet
Hippo
lol