how much of this is because I’m scumreading you less
fwiw I think my team-read earlier of Marshal/Derps/Vul was probably incorrect
I think Marshal would be pushing me harder if I were exactly right
Mm.
Do talk about it, please.
The reason I’m not pushing Derps independently is because I’m not confident enough in calling him a wolf without at least one ‘associated’ flip.
I think it’s an odd PoV when several of his early posts mention how he’s going to bring us a wolf pelt. That doesn’t read like someone who isn’t confident about pushing people.
the specific way she makes this random callout of Derps with no other context or anything prompting it in the thread is super typical of W/W distancing and isn’t a commonly-enough-known tell that people correct for it and avoid doing it to their partners
this is not ‘Marshal is pushing Derps? Marshal bus??’ to be clear, it has to do with how she makes the read with no prelude or followup
Basically, paints it as a bad idea to push Derps, even if Derps is a wolf, because it ‘doesn’t help.’ Right.
Hm.
can Marshal actually be a villager from my point of view
thinking face
non-me or Marshal players
Mistyx
SirDerpsAlot
EliThePsycho
Vulgard
ArcticXI
Hippoyeetus
Atlas
Blizer
remove the 2.5 people in my towncore (sorry Mist you’re a claimed PR which makes you only half a person)
SirDerpsAlot
EliThePsycho
Vulgard
ArcticXI
Blizer
think Arctic’s EoD3 likely makes him just a villager (also if Marshal’s a villager then she’s confidently vouching for him and I care enough about Marshal’s reads to weight that >0)
SirDerpsAlot
EliThePsycho
Vulgard
Blizer
don’t think Vul <-> Blizer are W/W
Derps works with anyone
Eli works with anyone but I don’t think he’s a wolf and most of his wolf equity comes from the possibility of worlds where he’s been coached by Marshal
ehhhh
I’m coming up with ‘if the rest of my reads are right she’s just a wolf’ but that ‘if’ is making me really nervous
I didn’t say this at the time but the way Atlas responded to my townread on him by saying he didn’t see why people would townread him is >rand W because most villagers think they’re being villagery. still think he’s probably a villager just… it wasn’t a great post.
I had the same thought, and then I was like “but does a wolf at Atlas’s level of experience actually say that?”
I never saw you talk about Hippo. Why is Hippo a villager?
If your PoE is correct, in theory you have one room for the misyeet between us, if you think we’re V/W. How do you want to approach this?
I think it’s more likely to come from a wolf of Atlas’s experience level than from a wolf of, I don’t know, Hippo or you or Marshal’s experience level
+ I thought his EoD3 was reasonably villager when I read it as part of EoD3 rather than as isolated posts
Is there no fear of people being like “I guess I have to stop townreading Atlas now” in a wolf at Atlas’s level?
I’m not specifically making a V/W association between the two of you
just not-W/W
tbh my plan is ‘kill whoever I think is the likeliest wolf without worrying about teams’
I’ll worry about teams if I’m around for LyLo
1 Like
shrug
I do still think he’s more likely a villager than not
but he’s almost the exact experience level that’s like ‘looking like you want to be townread is wolfy, so I’m going to do not that’
(also fwiw I’m not assuming that I can work from a starting point of ‘get a correct 4 person PoE, win’ because there are a decent number of people in game who were wolfreading lol and are varying levels of disinterested in actually reading me and/or repping a scumread)
If you want your PoE to contain three wolves (which you should), then that’s basically the association you’re making between me/Blizer if you’re slotting us into a preexisting Derps/Marshal PoE.
