[SFM] Evolution Mafia [Mafia wins]

16 H is not a completely reasonable amount of time to both go to sleep, wake up AND work (assuming Wazza has a life)

why would they replace in into top lynch before going to sleep knowing they wont be able to come online soon

They were both:
Online
Were first in line to replace
Wanted to replace

yes but that likelyhood in case of town based on this is same as randomly picking 6 people and saying there has to be scum there

yea but given situation it would make no sense to do that

What is consensus on Marshall’s alignment. I’d like to see them flip.

Its not random though.

Amelia flipped town. 6 people voted for her to die, including me. The odds of all 6 of us being wrong is just…not practical.

NULL

Not to discredit Wazza, but do you honestly think that they were aware of the gamestate before replacing in? I mean, they had to go back and re-read the OP. Not the most game-conscious person IMO.

there are enough of times town is lynched and many people on wagon are also town esp d1

I still stand by D1 read and I do think he could have done more when replacing in and during the 16h

Like be more productive IRL

Keyword: Many.

Can there be many on that wagon that are town? Yes.

Can all? Well, if that’s the case we just gave scum an absolute freebie. Odds are that it wasn’t THAT easy, they needed at least one person on board for this lynch.

or we dont assume that he does that

To what lynch?

If N.1 is town, they needed nothing to lynch town.

I’m referring to the Amelia lynch.

My consensus is that they die on EoD.

Why bother?

I will fight you :angry:

So do I.

N.1 was counterwagon, right?
If they are town… mafia wouldn’t need anything to lynch town.

yea but your argument was that it was impractical odds for so many people to be wrong so it was what I was responding to

the we go back to random argument