never bet your life on somebody’s flip if you’re a villager
it’s a surefire way to get somebody killed, and to demoralise and destabilise the village at that
I think the reason for Marshal’s (mostly tinfoil) theory is just villagery paranoia because we’ve mostly shot town today. I say we should still kill in PoE until wolves completely stop flipping, then we can re-evaluate.
Leafia might be too trusting, but this looks like someone trying to townread their team d1.
I think these posts are generally ok because I went through the same thought process in way.
Then Leafia goes and does this
I don’t like the misplaced trust in Vader. It either comes from a overly trusting towny or someone trying to tr their team d1.
This is a reasonable response, but I don’t like how there isn’t much of a follow up.
I really don’t like this post. Maybe Leafia is too trusting, but Seth wasn’t looking villagery at that point, so I don’t think it would be reasonable to give Seth a TR.
This is there, but almost everyone had cheese as a scum read, so it’s excusable.
In hindsight this is a good vote, but I feel Leafia messes up by leaving the wagon.
At this point most thought EVO was scum, but I think it wasn’t a good look to keep going after EVO after they came back later.
This was actually a good look for Marshal, but the reasoning behind it isn’t terrible.
It’s not best to judge someone on activity.
I could see this post coming from either alignment.
Leafia’s d1 ITA list. 2 out of 4 of those flipped town, but I wouldn’t mind a updated ITA list from Leafia.
I mean, anything is possible, but I would like to here your case against derps.
It’s good to read before you make a decision, but I could see this coming from a new towny or a wolf. This one is a null to me
Stop using activity to assume someone is scum
I really don’t like TRing Seth, but it could be from someone not experienced with this sight.
I think it’s possible that something is up with Vulgard, but I don’t like all the shade you do when you vote and such.
This isn’t a horrible vote, but Leafia eventually works back to EVO and I don’t know how I feel about that.
Why didn’t you try pushing Vulgard harder if you thought Vul was scum? I get that it’s somewhat difficult to push on experienced players, but I think you could at least try.
I don’t know how I feel about Leafia’s flip-floping with votes.
Case in point
Maybe I am wrong, but I just really don’t like flip-floppy votes.
Since Alice ended up dead this could possibly be good or bad for Leafia, but I really don’t like this slot throwing shade with every vote.
Lolselfresolving
I think Leafia saying Seth is scum is a decent look, but I wouldn’t put it past scum since Seth was outed at that point.
Alice always dies from being a target, but this post could go for either alignment
This looks like Leafia was trying to move shots from Mode
I like this vote, but I think not sticking with it is a pretty meh look
Again I want your case against Vul
Arete is decent at reading Vulgard, but there is a chance that they are both scum. I think both are capable, but this post isn’t terrible.
I kind of like this post
More shade from Leafia, which isn’t a good look in my eyes
I don’t know how I feel about this post
Did Leafia change their position on Vul overnight?
This is kind of stating the obvious even at that time
I really hate this post. Why lynch the potential wolf over the confirmed wolf?
But Seth was confirmed a wolf at that point. Take the obvious wolf out
Zone could die in ITAs tomorrow, so I don’t really like this reasoning.
This is a decent look in terms of Centuries
The reasoning behind this post is ok, but I don’t know enough about Leafia to say if they would out said ability as scum
This post is decent, but it could be a post getting their wolf buddy to come back
Who said you have to be invited?
I don’t know how I feel about this vote
This post is bad considering that Leafia TR centuries earlier
Again I don’t like this post, Leafia’s TR on centuries earlier to this and the shade on someone else is just bad in my opinion
I like this vote, but Leafia doesn’t stick with it
The reasoning isn’t bad here. We likely do have a wolf in the town core
This is a interesting take
I think Leafia is too trusting and of course I don’t like the vote, but that is what it is
like i guess Centuries is dead, and he was a PoE slot that needed resolving, but I can’t pretend it isn’t disheartening to have about 3 seperate people call it a hero shot when it plainly wasn’t
It looks like you’re forcing yourself to analyze when you have 0 stances, or you’re struggling with TMI. But you’re the one who decided to ISO Leafia, so you should probably have some stances…
Unless you were unable to find anything you could confidently push on, so instead you make these double-edged statements all the time. But if you’re a villager, then you could just… not quote the things you didn’t have a stance on… In the current form, it just looks like effort for the sake of effort.
