So I can see the Ici and Maxwell connection since he seemed to be defending Maxwell and telling him his vote was not good
Maxwell:
Beg and he shall receive.
/vote WazzaAzza
@Firekitten
Icibalus:
he’s obvious village
don’t do it
Maxwell:
Meh I’ll decide later
/unvote
@Firekitten
And FK said he had already found a friend when he declined. That can either be flavor or he actually meant Ici was in a chat already
Despite the mention of a certain detail, there’s nothing added to it. It’s only there to point something out.
DatBird:
So reading through everything here is my current reads
Townleans:
Solic: good town discussion, trying to get people to talk, and actively picking apart everything that people say
Geyde: Pushing people, being a town leader. I see this is as his usual playstyle.
Maxwell: I genuinely believe his AtE with Isaac’s death and feel his remorse for something he didn’t actually cause (it was isaacs fault). Now his interactions with Ici in the begining were weird, but i really gutfeel this town
Wazza: The reaction test was dumb, but his plays trying to get info out of Isaac and Nerbins seems like towny Wazza even if it comes with a lot of unessescary language
Squid: See this as town squid when they started giving their reads early and with talking on who to give the bomb to instead of just doing it behind the scenes. Overall the post that really sold it to me was the one where she didn’t defend herself, its just feels to genuine to fake
Isaac: his flip said so
Null:
Maximusprime: no content @MaximusPrime plz come and play
Celeste: I don’t really remember anything they have done other than vote Wazza, and saying Ici was a whiteknight whatever that means
Eevee: Weird choice in friend, since they are the most voted person atm. Wants the bomb, other than that not much to read
Nerbins: Not much but we know he has passives
Soul: No content, and when someone pointed it out, they talked about pushing inactives being sometimes scummy
Scumleans:
Ici: His interactions where he seemed to try and pocket Wazza, Isaac, Squid, and Maxwell. Then he pushes Solic in what feels like you point out my flaws Imma vote you. In that regard imma vote you sir
/vote Ici
@Firekitten
@Meteoro
It’s kind of odd that there are so many Townreads on this list and only one Scumread. And to be honest, I think Ici’s been also trying to get discussion going, just like in his explanation for Solic. To me, it seems like double standards are involved.
DatBird:
Icibalus:
The main thing that ticked me off about this readslist is the way he reads me in a completely different manner to how he reads everybody else
So first, I would like to say at the time I was trying to participate and due to my lack of time I thought writing a reads list would be the best way of showing that I’m trying my best to give my ideas and be useful. I didnt mean to tick you off and am sorry for doing so. You were my biggest scum read and it was mainly just a gut feeling. I then went and reread and reread to try and make a solid point against you so it didnt seem like I was randomly voting you and had an argument to why I was doing so. I get called out for random voting and called a sheep a lot when I dont provide this reasoning so I was trying to make a solid argument even if it seemed to you that I was contradicting what I was seeing in villagers as you said here.
Icibalus:
He pretty much reads all his village-reads as village because of their actions; of hunting down wolves. However, instead of reading me for wolfy behaviours, he suddenly brings up interactions in a way that haven’t even been mentioned before.
Now those things I brought up do remind me of wolfy behaviors but maybe that’s your thing I dont know your playstyle the best.
Icibalus:
It seemed to me like DatBird was copying somebody else’s reasoning without even considering it, which makes me feel like he was trying to get me mislynched but couldn’t find anything directly wolfy.
This was all me on the reasoning, even if it wasnt the best, but I’m not a great player as you can see. Imo the way you have been playing since day 3 of D1 and today, have changed my opinion on your wolf status.
Icibalus:
Of course, sheeping isn’t inherrently wolfy, but the fact he acts as if his read on me is entirely unique is reaallly off imo
And lastly this, it was my main way of trying to not seem like a sheep by trying to bring up my own reasoning for voting. If that’s not the way I should approach voting I’ll try and improve and improve. I wasnt trying to make it feel unique I was just trying to provide points of reasoning and if that’s wolfy, it’s my mistake for misinforming yall and I’ll try to adapt for the better.
To be honest, readlists aren’t the best way to contribute to the conversation even though they state your opinions or lack of them, depending on the situation. Next, he mentions that he’s not familiar with Ici’s playstyle. Now, I’m not so sure on this seeing as Bird has at least played a few games with Ici before, so I’m sure he would at least have some sort of familiarity with Ici. And if you’re not sure on someone’s playstyle, check a previous Town and Wolf game with them and compare how he acts in the current game. Don’t just take a guess. Now, the next post talking about the change of wolf status: Once again, there’s a claim, but there’s no evidence behind it, making the claim pointless and just filler. On the final post, he doesn’t even explain why he voted the way he did. All he did was apologize which makes me feel like he’s trying to gain sympathy points.
DatBird:
You sheeped with a scum.
Explain that would you
You mean a scum voted at the EoD someone I voted. I love how that’s my sheeping. That makes sense.
That didn’t answer Wazza’s question, it’s all just a bunch of senseless whining.
DatBird:
So that’s great and all, but where does that leave us. 
Who are your scumreads?
Atm I feel like Hjasik is easily my biggest scum read she seems to be just memeing to me. Now is that inherently scummy for memeing, no but it just feels like theres no point to it other than just to post.I had no clue on Maximus before he left since there wasnt much to read.
From what I can tell, Hjasik isn’t memeing, in fact, I think she’s one of the biggest contributors to this game at the moment.
DatBird:
You’re telling me that you read the thread and never ONCE saw Geyde vote me for “having weird interactions”? 
I saw Geydes posts, but I think you are focusing way to much on the interactions part when it was just a way to talk about the heavy amount of pocketing.
So is this a method of throwing shade because this is incredibly shadethrowy with no mention of accusing Ici as scum.
DatBird:
which clearly indicates you cared more about making the read appeal to people than making it actually accurate.
Bro so one what wasnt accurate about my post, I said that you were trying to pocket about four different people, and that your vote on Solic seemed very much just like you vote me I vote you. Two, sure I guess I made it appealing because I used “interactions” but that word wasnt the meat of that argument. Like if I didnt include it the post would be almost Identical. Like it was just a word.
This argument is less like an actual argument and more like shifting the blame to someone else on something completely unrelated.
Thank you for coming to my TED talk
/vote Datbird
@Firekitten
@Meteoro
