my main issue is that almost all of your arguments have a central focus on ambiguity - you don’t have much confidence in anything you say which seems to me like a way of avoiding blame if things went to shit (like min not voting on silviu, but supporting the push for example)
i’m gonna leave it here for tonight before i end up going down a rabbit hole of confirmation bias
but one final thought: even if you weren’t scum wha use would it be to keep people around who simply hop on pushes? say if a scum were to try for a mislynch -from this event you would be the first person they attempt to convince, and they would have a pretty good chance of doing so, which could cost us the game if it were to work. this is a liability