[SFM] Newbie-Friendly Pokèmon 9er - Town Win

[Arctic]

@Appelsiini

i still need to go over your reasoning for doing the RT

you sus min more than windward for hopping on the train because min didn’t vote and was more passive than windward? in my opinion that suggests min was more open to listening before jumping on the train whereas windward spared no time

can you please elaborate on what info you actually got

i would say it would be too obvious for a scum to jump on the train as quick as windward did, but since she’s new i think she could have still made that mistake

[Arctic]

replied to wrong person loloops

[Appelsiini]

You never claim unless you need to. Ever.

I guess I could make a readlist of some kind, I feel like not many would be excluded from my PoE right now.

[kiromishiro21]

Because min makes me remember my dear surge. He wanted to know everyone’s thoughts and he behaves like town in my opinion

[WindwardAway]

That’s a bit of a dangerous assumption, still. Everyone wants to know everyone’s thoughts, but oftentimes the strategy depends on your personality. Not every townie is going to interrogate thoroughly, and not every scum is going to be laid back.

[kiromishiro21]

That is true but my strategy is that … I always wait to see what others do and how they react to my “a little” silly plays. You seem good to me for saying what you said a while ago

[kiromishiro21]

I was suspicious of cloned but I think it’s because my subconscious is still mad at him. I don’t think I’m foolish enough to keep quiet if it’s scum. That would be suspicious. I think he keeps quiet to draw conclusions and let us play.

Edit: im = he is

[an_gorta_pratai]

@Appelsiini

Would you believe me if I said I had a secret toneread on you as a wolf

It depends, basically it depends on how you push said toneread

@WindwardAway

See, the problem I’m having right now is telling whether someone has a newbie attitude or if they’re just faking innocence. Especially for people who do have prior experience in social deduction games, who know they shouldn’t provide a weak defense, that sort of behavior would make me suspect something’s up.

The thing is, I started playing games like ToS and there isn’t much thought needed to go into those games. They are more popcorn type games and have a lower skill threshold, so I don’t think it will be as easy for newbies in FM to feign ignorance.

@kiromishiro21

You’re pro?

Don’t listen to them, I’m about average

@kiromishiro21

Let me play however I want. The only way I know to play is to be weird
If it seems suspicious to me I vote and if not … no

You playing weird doesn’t matter, but you do need to provide reasoning for your votes. The problem with townplay on this site is that people are lazy and never learn. I want to bring me and the people around me up in skill. That’s why I want people to provide reasoning

[kiromishiro21]

I would like to get to d2 to give further reasoning. I’m not used to voting on d1

[WindwardAway]

I feel like I just haven’t seen enough posts from Cloned to have an idea whether or not he’s scum. I’m still going back to sift through posts from everyone to get a better impression of some of you guys.

[YoubutWorse]

I think a good way to figure who scum are is seeing how they react to accusations. Kind of like what Appel did to Silviu in order to form a better opinion on him. So far the only two people to have been pushed on have been Silviu and Windward and I think if we are to find more scum we should push on more people.

[kiromishiro21]

@WindwardAway

I feel like I just haven’t seen enough posts from Cloned to have an idea whether or not he’s scum. I’m still going back to sift through posts from everyone to get a better impression of some of you guys.

That is why I feel that you are good. You will review everything and that makes a town

[kiromishiro21]

@YoubutWorse

So far the only two people to have been pushed on have been Silviu and Windward and I think if we are to find more scum we should push on more people.

We better do something more fun … Do you think I’m scum?

[Appelsiini]

It’s not about Min being more suspicious than Windward, as it’s more about the fact that it’s more useful to wait and see how Windward handles their scumread on Silviu whereas Min’s reaction was bad from the get-go.
I can believe that Windward did have a scumread on Silviu earlier, sure, but Min’s behavior was something I wanted to focus on, as it comes from scum more often than it comes from town.

I can see Windward’s initial reaction coming from both alignments, which is why I wanted to wait. I think your pushing has given me some info, even though pressuring her immediately wasn’t something I would’ve done there. I’ll need to analyze it more thoroughly later.

[YoubutWorse]

… yeah

[kiromishiro21]

xD

[WindwardAway]

Honestly? Not necessarily. I’m not going to say Arctic is wrong for voting me. I think he has his reasons for doing so in order to push for more information from me, and I honestly don’t have a very strong defense right now. I’m also not going to say you’re wrong for thinking that since I analyze things, I must be town. But be careful in how you read people’s actions and words!

[Appelsiini]

@YoubutWorse

I think if we are to find more scum we should push on more people.

If you had to choose one person to push right now, who would it be?

[kiromishiro21]

It was not an exciting response

[kiromishiro21]

@YoubutWorse

… yeah

Maybe you don’t want to attract much attention and you took a quiet repose