Thats fair, I forgot how vital you are as the only ti. I was just thinking “oh cloned protecting wind and kiro protecting cloned, if one of them is maf they just wont attack”
I do think that before that little thing earlier that Appel was a decent bit towny. Like they were doing all of the things that town usually does, but Appel is good enough to fake it.
regardless of whether she’s town or mafia giving up like that was a really bad play and may cost us the game if she’s town
if the only thing stopping gorta being mafia is due to a scumteam not making sense, then we need to consider the possibility of some distancing going on, especially if appel flips town
2 Likes
Also:
- If one of Appel/Arctic/Gorta/Worse (whichever 3 are left) dies, we don’t have much information.
- If Kiro dies, the killer could be pretty much anyone, and it’s not really any better information than if one of the other 3 dies.
- If Cloned dies, Kiro didn’t heal him and would be a prime suspect for lynching.
- If I die, Cloned did not guard me and is not guarding me.
But:
- The mafia kind of needs the tracker dead. With every passing day I’m alive, I can dig up more dirt on them, especially with fewer players left.
- In order to kill me, the mafia either needs the protectives dead or has to fake claim that there’s a protective where there isn’t. So the protectives would be the first target.
- If the mafia want to avoid suspicion by neither killing the protectives nor the investigative, they’re digging themselves a grave. That would leave 3 PR claims and 2 VT claims, so it would be easy for me to track and extremely hard for them to kill.
1 Like
Jesus christ imagine how much shit we would be in if wind was maf, hes like the only person I 100% believe
I said before that the primary reason I would suspect her is because she’s been nullread/townlean on basically everyone’s list. I know that’s a bad reason to say someone’s a wolf, but she was doing a really good job of evading detection in that case, and that would be a wolfy play. Nobody had her on their scumlist and nobody had her as locktown.
Well, yes. I’m still trying to figure things out and I guess I concluded that out of Gorta/Kiro/Worse there’s likely only one wolf.
something just doesn’t feel right about this
appel’s argument has been much stronger than gorta’s and i just feel guilty that the reason we are trusting gorta over her is because ‘it doesn’t make sense for gorta to be scum with anyone’
i already said this but why would appel just give up like that if she were mafia, it would seem like a very easy mislynch opportunity to continue pushing and get gorta killed
plus if she were mafia i doubt she would have randomly accused me and YBW, that just seems like a death sentence
unfortunately i have nothing better to suggest
thks?
It’s also because Gorta has consistently given the reasons he thinks Appel is scum, as well as linking previous games to underline his point. Appel, on the other hand, has said she has a bad townread on Gorta but wants to vote him out anyway, then she voted him, got called out for doing so, unvoted and voted Worse instead.
i mean theyve got a good point, its your second game and my first
Im put off about that too, but the fact she pushed gorta for literaly days, and then just gives up doesnt sit right.
The thing is, I know I shouldn’t be speculating on setup but I don’t think the hosts would make the game so unfair as to make two very inexperienced players both wolves.
hi I’m back after lunch
…I’m not liking appel for backing off of what is effectively a thunderdome
the worst thing about forum games is telling the difference between people doing stupid things as town and people who are actually evil
that has literally been the entire basis of this game with silviu’s mislynch, gorta’s vote change which made little sense and now appel’s actions
1 Like
Right now, the majority vote is still on Appel (2 votes). We don’t need to rush to put more votes on her, but if anyone really thinks she shouldn’t be voted, they’d better vote now and give their reasons.
100% agree. But this is also a newbie game, which makes it even more difficult lol.
What wind said. From my understanding its between Me/Gorta/Appel. Me and gorta have voted appel, anyone have a good reason to why people should vote me or gorta?