[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

[ChopChop]

@Whysper

@Aelin

How about I appeal to your math:
Gorta has discarded a town alignment/role, and has claimed a role that only comes from town.
“18% of the time, three town role cards.”

@Aelin

I’m saying: 82% chance of a person being scum, they’re acting scummy, and we’re letting them go because lol!Prince

Even though I’ve been scum leaning Gorta, I don’t think he’s worth pursuing at this point. We have other slots to solve. I think most people understand he’s in the PoE and that we should look at him again down the road.

I agree with this

[ChopChop]

@Whysper

Hmmm, I’m not sure about those partners, but yeah, scum leaning him for the moment.

Well what’s your partner solve?

[clonedcheese]

@Whysper

I’m curious if he’ll come back yet this day.

im trying my best
plz dont hammer I should be done in 7 hours

[Whysper]

@ChopChop

ll what’s your partner solve?

Well, at the moment I don’t have Cloned partnered with anyone since not much to go on. He could even be solo I suppose. Or did you see something in particular that makes you partner him with ATNo and Ami?

Actually, I’m still not sure I saw reasoning on Ami as scum. I think I saw someone mention her aggressiveness, but I’ve seen people be aggressive like that as town.

[GGhana]

ami has not been shitposting

ami when town shitposts

@Ami explain urself or ur lock scum

[Whysper]

I could see ATNo and Gorta potentially being partnered together.

@an_gorta_pratai

I am the damn town one shot prince. This role is more powerful for me because my reads are pretty damn powerful and I get voted out very early as of late, so anything that extends my life is powerful for me.

@ATNoName

…

whatever this entire thread killed my will to play this game.

and I already speculated that you didn’t pick a stronger invest role, but like nobody listened because everything overshadowed it.

His early speculation that no one listened to could be TMI on Gorta’s role.

@an_gorta_pratai

they don’t listen “what could be stronger than a town tracker” “why did Gorta throw away town tracker” it never ends and was just going to clog the thread

@ATNoName

Hey @an_gorta_pratai, let’s just talk about Eevee/Wiisp interaction before I dive deeper into insanity.

@ATNoName

I guess no Eevee/Wiisp conversation

@an_gorta_pratai

What are you thinking?

@ATNoName

The entire point of Towncred.

Currently, Wiisp picked miller over cop and Eevee is suspecting Wiisp of picking miller for towncred.

Who do you believe? (I couldn’t think of a better question since it’s 1 am for me.

@an_gorta_pratai

I guess that claim is used to possibly get away with claiming town as mafia? How experienced is Wiisp?

@ATNoName

According to Wiisp themselves, they are a veteran player.

like it’s quite interesting.

Oh yeah I forgot that Wiisp’s defense is that he thought that Psychiatrist was useless

@an_gorta_pratai

I don’t know how I feel about that

@ATNoName

I’m gonna talk about it later since I’m half asleep.

If I ever get on by EOD, we should start talking about possible scenarios.

Something about this interaction between ATNo and Gorta feels fake. Like just a way for both of them to appear to be solving together.

[Aelin]

At this point, I think what we should be doing is
Execute AT
And, if Eevee agrees, shooting Gorta tonight, which then kills Apprentice by proxy

[GGhana]

I think Eevee is shooting Onie, which I personally am fine with

[Aelin]

Those posts where people say something, and in the same post, go,

“Oh wait I forgot (evidence that contradicts them) lol”

[Aelin]

I hate those with a burning passion

[Whysper]

@Aelin

And, if Eevee agrees, shooting Gorta tonight, which then kills Apprentice by proxy

@GGhana

I think Eevee is shooting Onie, which I personally am fine with

I think Eevee is going to be leaving it ambiguous either way, so no point in pressing him for a specific target.

[Whysper]

Probably good to leave it ambiguous anyway so that scum can’t protect or plan as easily.

[Ami]

dont have the energy to shitpost in all honesty

[Aelin]

This is very true. Besides, it’s not like we can force Eevee to do anything 100% wouldn’t put it past him to shoot someone who was trying to force him into shooting their target

[Whysper]

@GGhana

ami has not been shitposting

ami when town shitposts

Ahhh, is this their meta? I’m not familiar with them. This is the first game I’ve played with them.

[ChopChop]

@osieorb18

@Whysper

@eevee

Osie claim makes no sense either.

I can bite into mod giving him wrong card, despite wanting to pick scum.

But I cannot understand why mod would give him role from one, modifier from second and aligment from third.

Like… wtf.

Yes, this still bothers me a lot, too. Also the fact that CRich never even hinted at a problem like this having occurred. And he was definitely complaining about other stuff in the game.

It wasn’t even talked about in the role PM. I think CRich understood the role system even less well than I did.

Did he discuss it in Scum Chat then?

[ChopChop]

@osieorb18
You legit stated CRich said something about it and I never seen him do it.
Would you like to quote it or retract what you said?

[ChopChop]

The only thing that makes sense is Role PM but now you saying it ain’t the case

[GGhana]

I don’t think quoting from your role pm is allowed

[ChopChop]

He said it wasn’t from his role PM