[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

[GGhana]

@Arctic

i’ve said it before and i’ll say it again - i highly doubt osie is scum- why would they come to this site and lie about a moderror in their first game to angleshoot? i really do think at this point there is a second psychotrooper due to the double redcheck and the fact it is in no way favourable for a scum to 1 for 1 right now especially with a dead psychotrooper already

i mean

look at my math

[GGhana]

Also since you clearly had time to read the entire thread and all you can say is whining about my tunnels? Seriously?

[GGhana]

@Arctic

saying this indicates that you want me to be scum presumably just so you are correct, rather than because you still believe your read is genuine

therefore you aren’t looking at my slot objectively and demonstrate confirmation bias - so how are any of your reads reliable?

wow amazing, all the shade because of a joke post very classy

[GGhana]

@Arctic

but even if i was rb’ed this is a stretch and you know it, you aren’t accounting for the possibility of a kill overlap or someone being healed (like you)

this is literally a lie and you know it

[GGhana]

so sorry sweaty, that wallpost aint gonna get u out of the burn box smh my head

[GGhana]

Anyways, @Whysper if you’re still here what do you think of Gorta? I was kinda scum-reading them but I am worried that it’s just because it’s how gorta usually plays. Is Gorta playing similarly to this game for example?

Return of King Kong - YOU LOSE - [4/10]

Thanks

[Whysper]

@GGhana

Anyways, @Whysper if you’re still here what do you think of Gorta? I was kinda scum-reading them but I am worried that it’s just because it’s how gorta usually plays. Is Gorta playing similarly to this game for example?

I was about to head to bed, but I can stay up a bit. I have him down as a scum-lean, but this is mostly based on his role choice and his interaction with ATNo. His other posts and tone could fit in with his town meta. I’m use to thinking his town meta seeming scummy, so I tend not to read him for tone. Though I don’t know that I’ve seen a game with him as scum. I started looking through that one you linked and found where he was discovered as scum, so I’ll review it now.

[GGhana]

yeah basically im only scumreading him because of his day 2 push, and his interactions with AT and Ami

[Whysper]

But I’ve mostly set him aside because of his claim and there being other people with more against them

[Whysper]

Looking through this other game, his tone still does seem similar to his town meta. Continuing to look and see if there’s less solving though.

[Whysper]

Haha, I like how in this wolf game he still describes his reads as “an elaborate mix of meta, patterns, and gut.”

[Arctic]

@GGhana

this is literally a lie and you know it

can you elaborate
saying i’m lying isn’t very useful
explain how you accounted for a kill overlap because it’s pretty clear you didn’t

@GGhana

Also since you clearly had time to read the entire thread and all you can say is whining about my tunnels? Seriously?

…did you really not look at what else i said?

@GGhana

wow amazing, all the shade because of a joke post very classy

the point still stands
you are in confbias and the post showed you just want me to be scum

[GGhana]

@Arctic

…did you really not look at what else i said?

all you said after that is basically just “osie town, ami scum” and not anything useful or productive

[GGhana]

@Arctic

the point still stands
you are in confbias and the post showed you just want me to be scum

are you seriously saying my joke post proves my reads are wrong?

[clonedcheese]

@GGhana

@min

Osie flips town, what does that tell us?

Osie flips wolf but not werewolf, what will THAT tell us?

we have a second psychotrooper in play

It’s unlikely but it’s possible

Is there a possibility that people are just
Lying
In the case that osie flips scum

[GGhana]

@Arctic

can you elaborate
saying i’m lying isn’t very useful
explain how you accounted for a kill overlap because it’s pretty clear you didn’t

@GGhana

alright so, let me explain with my gigantic brain why ami is boxed in

so we have mafia, aliens, werewolves, and a dead sk

night 2 if ami is telling the truth, the sk got a kill and she got a kill and both mafia and werewolves would have missed a kill. So therefore Min would’ve protected the night kill target, or Arctic wouldve had to have done a factional kill and gotten roleblocked

night 2 if she is lying, the sk got a kill, she did a factional kill. and the other faction didnt kill.

which one is more likely to you?

cough

I’ll give you a pass for this one because my wording was a bit unclear and I edited it.

[clonedcheese]

@GGhana

i mean

look at my math

I need you to show your work becausw i got vastly different odds

[GGhana]

3/146 odds of drawing psychotrooper, repeat again therefore its 3/146(3/146)

could you show me what answer you got and how you got it?

[GGhana]

This gets a bit more complicated assuming you can draw two of the same rolecards, so those are just approximate odds.

[Arctic]

@GGhana

are you seriously saying my joke post proves my reads are wrong?

freudian slip, idk?
whether or not it’s a joke it’s pretty clear that you just want me to be scum so you are right

like tsumugi said

also, your post doesn’t consider anything to do with a kill overlap

and since i wasn’t role blocked and just didn’t submit an action, that’s probably what happened