After I more than modkilled you for a similar play.
Just putting this out there: If I was scum cupid, I wouldn’t claim as such in the thread.
Look, it doesn’t matter if they or you are scummy to what I said.
It matters for me that you are fitting arguments to your PoV.
Express yours, but not by bending math formulas to it.
Math is not gonna change just to prove you are not scum.
You’ve invested infinitely more time and energy into the math here than I did. I barely commented on the probabilities because it wasn’t important. I didn’t think much about them because, again, they aren’t important. When talking about math, you might have even put more thought into the probabilities than every single other player combined.
Since the probabilities still aren’t important, are you down to talk about, well, the actual Nightkill mechanics and actual reads on people’s posts (not just based on fake claims)?
Or is this me changing the topic in some awful direction away from the point of the thread?
I thought we were here to play a game of mafia. I’ve been openly asking people to communicate in order to further town interaction and progress reads.
There’s a joke about Moses and Jesus playing golf. Moses hits the ball and gets a respectable couple of feet from the hole. Jesus hits the ball into a tree. He waves his hand, and the ball flies out of the tree and into the hole. He turns to Moses with a smug look on his face. Moses looks in the direction of the hole, scratches his beard, then turns to Jesus and says: “Look, do you want to play golf, or do you want to fuck around?”
And so, I ask… Do you want to play mafia or do you want to fuck around?
im not sure what the point of this post is but whatever.
Actually could you make a case about Tsumugi? I know you think theyre scum so I’d just like if you could put all the reasons in a paragraph
This post, and this post
Don’t make sense together
Already explained why this doesn’t matter. (Tsumugi can be a mafia seer who still got a 100% legit peek)
I dont think that’s something you can just decide
anyways
everyone follow my lead because who needs a towncore because i am the towncore
@osieorb18 I want to know your full case on Tsumugi
@Tsumugi-Shirogane I want you to act more townie
@Ami I want you to stop being a N E R D (only nerds rely so heavily on math smh my head :joy_nerd:)
@clonedcheese I want you to do anything productive and stop commentating.
@TrustworthyLiberal I want your slot to be easier to read
@eevee I want you to marry me
i think thats everything
Votecount
| Voted | Count | Accusers |
|---|---|---|
| Osieorb | 2/7 | GGhana, Tsumugi-Shirogane |
| Eevee | 1/7 | Apprentice |
| Surge | 1/7 | osieorb18 |
| Tsumu | 1/7 | Ami |
- Chad not voting at all for a long while, particularly in the early game, is a scumtell.
- Chad being oddly low activity for a long while, particularly in the early game, is a scumtell.
- Chad having very little investment in the thread outside of a tunnel here and there, is a scumtell.
- When Chad was posting, their posts weren’t particularly productive. This is not unusual as either alignment, but there’s a veneer of “trying to look productive while staying under the radar” that is again scummy.
Chad’s first semi-real semi-productive post is questioning your read in #2482. That’s almost halfway into the game thus far. It’s also after the start of D2. There was NOTHING productive on D1. Nothing. Not even a little bit. The closest there was to a useful post during D1 was a single, easy, targeting strategy post, which is mostly useless wine at best. They followed #2482 up with #2493, in which they pat themself on the back for their “earlier productivity” in the form of their shallow, unproductive, target advice post. They followed this up with a defense of Arctic, then pointed out that Eevee and Arctic shouldn’t be taken off the ambiguity table. There’s no pressure anywhere. Whatsoever. They’re not trying to progress the game at all. they just want to coast and stay alive. In response to TL’s first red check: “even if the check is real you should go next.” Uhh… what? That’s insane. They then defend themself some more. When not under serious pressure. They then go for their role claim on Wiisp in #3529. At this point, they have posted essentially nothing of value. And we’re supposed to believe that they were just a cop waiting for the right moment? That’s absurd. They also fumbled their claim. They “thought Wisp was a miller, not a werewolf miller”, but checked Wiisp, as a Seer, because “You check miller claims.” Ummm… what? Either one knows that the miller claim is relevant or they don’t. One doesn’t get to eat their cake and have it too. There’s even a lie in how they heard about the game. I didn’t know about this game until long after they had joined. Chad presents themself as “lost on what’s going on” and “knowing noone in the game”. They then, rather than voting the player who they have reason to believe lied about their claim, vote for a DIFFERENT red check. Either both red checks would be affected by a psychotrooper or neither would be. They just had psychotrooper explained to them. They posit that TL is aligned with the psychotrooper. Great. Fearmongering. They then come to the conclusion that checking a werewolf miller as seer would be a bad idea. Uhh, what? And TMI slip on Apprentice in #3825 after waffling for a while with no real content. Blah blah blah, this ISO goes on with nothing of value.
Then we go onto D3. Fresh out of the gate in #5226, they start in on their gambit. Chad’s follow-up argument against my claim is bad meta of a scumgame that they’ve seen only twice. The recent time, claiming was not relevant. The previous time was about three years ago. They then finish that sentence with Chad’s standard Trumpian “Everyone’s out to get me” philosophy. “Osie will turn this against me.” Well, if you’re actually town and Osie’s scum, and you have a redcheck on Osie, then you shouldn’t be worried about Osie turning your CLAIMED CHECK against you. Unless there’s something not right about your claim, which that VERY SAME POST would be what suggests it. Chad then continues to want TL to be killed or eliminated. Chad then rolefishes GGhana. Blatantly. And casts doubt on someone who supports Chad’s check. And then we have more “Osie’s out to get me.” Great. Chad does this no matter what the alignments are nowadays. “Osie’s out to get me.” They inherited it from Wiisp, who has mostly stopped it since Wiisp understands that it’s not only bad play, but comes across as being intentionally unpleasant.
I left off here at #5278. I can go on, but that’s already more than enough for a strong scumread on Chad.
I am playing mafia and acussing you to bend reality to fit image you are trying to show others.
Probability might not be important or it might be important.
Point stands - you try to fit reality so it fits you, instead of drawing conclusions from what is already existing.
Then make a case on me based on my posts. Because nobody actually has done so. The only case on me based on my posts has been “We think that Osie is a cheating angleshooter.”
One of them is talking about nightkills, the other is talking about roles. The role probability and the comparison to nightkills are mostly unimportant, because the idea of the nightkills being blocked as successfully as you suggest is already absurd.
Unlike anything I’ve read of your posts, I’ve actually read people on behaviour this game. I’m sure I could have missed some of that in the earlier phases from you, but I’ve been doing it pretty much constantly. You’ve also accused me of cheating. So again I ask, do you want to play mafia or do you want to fuck around?