[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

[GGhana]

The thing I don’t get is why merc wouldn’t just idk

Change it back or something. In hindsight it kinda makes my townread on them go up in smoke because it just doesn’t make sense

[osieorb18]

@GGhana

i basically just dont want to yeet any of the following

(min,surge,whysper,light,troch,wiisp)

but it doesnt take a genius to figure out these are town slots

Why on Whysper? I can see more reasons on pretty much all of the other ones.

[GGhana]

Because basically every single one of their posts feels towny to me, plus they get easier to read as the game goes on

[Whysper]

@Aelin

How about I appeal to your math:
Gorta has discarded a town alignment/role, and has claimed a role that only comes from town.
“18% of the time, three town role cards.”

@Aelin

I’m saying: 82% chance of a person being scum, they’re acting scummy, and we’re letting them go because lol!Prince

Even though I’ve been scum leaning Gorta, I don’t think he’s worth pursuing at this point. We have other slots to solve. I think most people understand he’s in the PoE and that we should look at him again down the road.

[Whysper]

@osieorb18

It wasn’t even talked about in the role PM. I think CRich understood the role system even less well than I did.

But wouldn’t CRich have at least noticed that his alignment was wrong and said something?

[Whysper]

CRich isn’t the type of person I see missing something like that.

[ChopChop]

@osieorb18

@GGhana

i basically just dont want to yeet any of the following

(min,surge,whysper,light,troch,wiisp)

but it doesnt take a genius to figure out these are town slots

Why on Whysper? I can see more reasons on pretty much all of the other ones.

Whysper is ObvTown.

[Whysper]

@clonedcheese

Ami ISO cuz I’m lazy

…

@clonedcheese

I don’t know ami enough to know if this is town or scum

why did i do this

Haha, what kind of ISO is this? And yeah, why did you do that?

@clonedcheese

time for AT next

@clonedcheese

actually Ima just read d2 through like i said i would

I’m curious if he’ll come back yet this day.

[ChopChop]

InB4 Cloned is scum with Ami and AT like I predicted.

[Whysper]

Hmmm, I’m not sure about those partners, but yeah, scum leaning him for the moment.

[ChopChop]

@Whysper

@Aelin

How about I appeal to your math:
Gorta has discarded a town alignment/role, and has claimed a role that only comes from town.
“18% of the time, three town role cards.”

@Aelin

I’m saying: 82% chance of a person being scum, they’re acting scummy, and we’re letting them go because lol!Prince

Even though I’ve been scum leaning Gorta, I don’t think he’s worth pursuing at this point. We have other slots to solve. I think most people understand he’s in the PoE and that we should look at him again down the road.

I agree with this

[ChopChop]

@Whysper

Hmmm, I’m not sure about those partners, but yeah, scum leaning him for the moment.

Well what’s your partner solve?

[clonedcheese]

@Whysper

I’m curious if he’ll come back yet this day.

im trying my best
plz dont hammer I should be done in 7 hours

[Whysper]

@ChopChop

ll what’s your partner solve?

Well, at the moment I don’t have Cloned partnered with anyone since not much to go on. He could even be solo I suppose. Or did you see something in particular that makes you partner him with ATNo and Ami?

Actually, I’m still not sure I saw reasoning on Ami as scum. I think I saw someone mention her aggressiveness, but I’ve seen people be aggressive like that as town.

[GGhana]

ami has not been shitposting

ami when town shitposts

@Ami explain urself or ur lock scum

[Whysper]

I could see ATNo and Gorta potentially being partnered together.

@an_gorta_pratai

I am the damn town one shot prince. This role is more powerful for me because my reads are pretty damn powerful and I get voted out very early as of late, so anything that extends my life is powerful for me.

@ATNoName

…

whatever this entire thread killed my will to play this game.

and I already speculated that you didn’t pick a stronger invest role, but like nobody listened because everything overshadowed it.

His early speculation that no one listened to could be TMI on Gorta’s role.

@an_gorta_pratai

they don’t listen “what could be stronger than a town tracker” “why did Gorta throw away town tracker” it never ends and was just going to clog the thread

@ATNoName

Hey @an_gorta_pratai, let’s just talk about Eevee/Wiisp interaction before I dive deeper into insanity.

@ATNoName

I guess no Eevee/Wiisp conversation

@an_gorta_pratai

What are you thinking?

@ATNoName

The entire point of Towncred.

Currently, Wiisp picked miller over cop and Eevee is suspecting Wiisp of picking miller for towncred.

Who do you believe? (I couldn’t think of a better question since it’s 1 am for me.

@an_gorta_pratai

I guess that claim is used to possibly get away with claiming town as mafia? How experienced is Wiisp?

@ATNoName

According to Wiisp themselves, they are a veteran player.

like it’s quite interesting.

Oh yeah I forgot that Wiisp’s defense is that he thought that Psychiatrist was useless

@an_gorta_pratai

I don’t know how I feel about that

@ATNoName

I’m gonna talk about it later since I’m half asleep.

If I ever get on by EOD, we should start talking about possible scenarios.

Something about this interaction between ATNo and Gorta feels fake. Like just a way for both of them to appear to be solving together.

[Aelin]

At this point, I think what we should be doing is
Execute AT
And, if Eevee agrees, shooting Gorta tonight, which then kills Apprentice by proxy

[GGhana]

I think Eevee is shooting Onie, which I personally am fine with

[Aelin]

Those posts where people say something, and in the same post, go,

“Oh wait I forgot (evidence that contradicts them) lol”

[Aelin]

I hate those with a burning passion