[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 7 (5/19) - Mafia Wins

[Whysper]

@GGhana

Ami - Mostly inactive, and their interactions with AT felt fake as hell
Cloned - Mostly slanking, plus they slank a lot as scum
Onie - I want to townread this slot, but their story about the mod error makes no sense
Arctic - They act very cagey, and dont really share their reads. This feels a lot like a noob who rolled scum their first game
Tsumugi - Again very inactive, and a lot of their reads feel very obvious. Plus their role doesnt seem that useful (im 90% we dont have werewolves at this point)

Also gorta would be in this PoE if he didnt claim prince because, of his interactions with AT and a lot of his reads conflict (wiisp and min especially) so it feels like his logic feels forced.

I agree with most of this PoE except Arctic. I think he’s just noob trying to get use to playing but making some posts that look a bit scummy. Like I know there was that thing about him just taking my CRich read and pushing on that for awhile. But I could see a new town player doing that as a way to interact. Then because he was pressured on that, I think he’s been a little more reluctant to do anymore reads or interact much more.

And yeah, you are right that even though Gorta looks suspicious, he can be left for later still because of the claim. Maybe someone will eventually take care of him overnight.

[an_gorta_pratai]

@TrustworthyLiberal

wait why are we not voting either the person tracked to a kill or the red check…

Regardless thats where we should be no?

In this I would rather lynch the red. The only thing is Ghana should track Ami again, but I like how Ami handled that claim

@Whysper

Yeah, I’ve been thinking Gorta might be partners with ATNo. I found that series of interactions between them potentially fake solving.

I never interacted with AT. I don’t remember even talking to AT.

@Whysper

Haha, never heard anyone talk about nullish vibes. Town vibes and scum vibes, yes, but not nullish vibes. Is there even a vibe for that, or is that just the absence of vibes?

When I get null reads like that I don’t really get anything alignment indicative. Like Ghana has some genuine moments, but at the same time they have some posts that make me question if they are town. I would say as of now that it’s leaning scum, but Ghana has this fake/forced feel to them.

[an_gorta_pratai]

also I will look at TL soon

[TrustworthyLiberal]

I am not the person you will read into.

[GGhana]

@an_gorta_pratai

When I get null reads like that I don’t really get anything alignment indicative. Like Ghana has some genuine moments, but at the same time they have some posts that make me question if they are town. I would say as of now that it’s leaning scum, but Ghana has this fake/forced feel to them.

how dare u say this when I have a

HARD
E A R N E D
W
O
L
F
P
E
L
T

[Whysper]

@an_gorta_pratai

I haven’t interacted any with AT. I know AT defended my slot a few times, which is weird considering I am not mafia. How do my reads on Wiisp and min conflict?

Umm, what do you mean you didn’t interact any with ATNo? You had a 1-on-1 with ATNo about Eevee and Wiisp. Are you mixing up interactions between the main thread and scum chat?

[SFM] Va-11 Hall-A Greatest Idea Game Thread - Day 3 (14/19) - Ping host to vote

I could see ATNo and Gorta potentially being partnered together. His early speculation that no one listened to could be TMI on Gorta’s role. Something about this interaction between ATNo and Gorta feels fake. Like just a way for both of them to appear to be solving together.

[GGhana]

@Whysper

I agree with most of this PoE except Arctic. I think he’s just noob trying to get use to playing but making some posts that look a bit scummy. Like I know there was that thing about him just taking my CRich read and pushing on that for awhile. But I could see a new town player doing that as a way to interact. Then because he was pressured on that, I think he’s been a little more reluctant to do anymore reads or interact much more.

I think I might keep this in mind. But I do think it all goes in the bin if Ami flips villager. So I think this just adds to the reasons to kill Ami

[an_gorta_pratai]

I don’t read people based on how many wolf pelts they have. We lost in that one SFoL game with Alice as BD cult leader because Alice got the most wolf pelts. This is also multiball, so yeah I don’t solve based on pelts. You scumread me and I hard pushed Soul d1, so if you read me by those merits I can’t be a wolf.

[Whysper]

@GGhana

I think I might keep this in mind. But I do think it all goes in the bin if Ami flips villager. So I think this just adds to the reasons to kill Ami

Yeah, that’s fair. I’m also willing to reconsider Arctic again after we get more info on others.

[an_gorta_pratai]

I’ll be honest, I just woke up from a nap and didn’t even remember that interaction.

[GGhana]

bruh it was a joke

[an_gorta_pratai]

I clearly can’t read jokes

[an_gorta_pratai]

but I’ll be honest, I don’t remember much about that interaction with AT. I would have bussed AT hard if we were scum together to avoid something like this all together.

[Whysper]

@GGhana

heres a really :thonk:er. But what if tsumugi is a member of the mafia who claimed to check the miller and got them as not a werewolf to confirm themselves as a seer

Ahhh interesting. Because she already knew there was a Psychotrooper. Hmmm.

One thing I’ve been wondering about is why ATNo gave up so easily. He was being suspected, but he probably could have turned things around if he tried a bit. But he just gave up and starting allowing himself to act wolfie. People were only speculating about a possible Psychotrooper. If he could have fought and survived, people would still be wondering what the chances are for a Psychotrooper. There was never even a ML yet for someone that got a wrong check, so kind of wasted the whole Psychotrooper thing.

[GGhana]

@Whysper

One thing I’ve been wondering about is why ATNo gave up so easily. He was being suspected, but he probably could have turned things around if he tried a bit. But he just gave up and starting allowing himself to act wolfie. People were only speculating about a possible Psychotrooper. If he could have fought and survived, people would still be wondering what the chances are for a Psychotrooper. There was never even a ML yet for someone that got a wrong check, so kind of wasted the whole Psychotrooper thing.

That’s exactly why I checked Ami, that felt like a bus and I think I was right.

[ChopChop]

@an_gorta_pratai
Who’s your top TR?

[ChopChop]

For me it’s a tie between Tro and Min.
Apprentice is also there as practically confirmed town Via Tro but w/e.

[an_gorta_pratai]

I would say Trochi and by extension App

[ChopChop]

Ok now who’s your top SR?

[ChopChop]

Other then Osie of course.