The difference here is that I am arbiter and he should have no reason to know it is cult
Well we can’t exactly lynch today but go on
Only Arbiter learns that, and they are unique.
Thanks if you’re arbiter
Its byzantium game
Apparently I can’t quote previous messages.
That’s why I struggle to go with this proposition.
I believe there is one NE that has knowledge of the game type beforehand
Nope there isn’t
Fyi paladin and sheriff were previously unconvertible and unique and had only just being changed to being non-unique and thus a viable fakeclaim for scum
And what does that have to do with this?
It seems to me that you are white-knighting a suspicious player, and have tried to make the read on him based off of activity instead of what they have said.
To me, it would then appear that you really want to save them from the lynch / night kill.
There is no pronce sadly
Everything now that I think about it
I was just thinking about that there is no usual strong Town killer aka jailor
No, I think some thing should be left unsaid to WIFOM scum
Was Paladin unique/unconvertable at the time of NFoL 2?
No they weren’t