Honestly, Iām somewhat dissatisfied with my own PoE of just Seth/Gorta in it right now. Looking at our readlists, thereās an overwhelming lack of different SRās. Like, the only opinions that stand out to me are SDAās (I can partially feel him on Appel and Alice).
This isā¦ worrying.
I think Iāll need to use this night to reevaluate.
Lists are sorted within tiers. People closer to the top of the post are more town/less scum.
Townreads/townleans
Ans - at this point I have Ans as close to locktown, I can elaborate if people really want to but Iāve been talking about my read on him a fair amount anyway and itās not like this is particularly controversial.
katze - I think on reflection that the complicated alch claim stuff is more likely to come from town, particularly the part where afterwards she called me out for the fact that she could have been feeling me out for how to use it to pocket me (as opposed to just using it to pocket me). Also I thought his response to my sort-by-postcount readlist was decent (he didnāt seem to care about trying to change where he was on it, I think scum!katze would have been more bothered by it).
Intensify - I believe they actually had a day ability that they wanted to know how to use and most classes with day abilities are town their general approach to the thread is consistent with someone who doesnāt have partners to help them out, which makes me think they are probably town.
Nappy - I vaguely remember seeing some things I liked from him but I donāt actually remember what.
TBE - I vaguely remember thinking he was weird early on but not why, lately heās been improving and his readlist seemed basically decent (his thoughts in it felt real + make sense, and it doesnāt do any of the Standard Newbwolf Things like hedging).
CRichard - at this point Iām just lazily reading them on meta + they havenāt done anything overtly wolfy, so probablyā¢ town.
Cheese - his early posts displayed a lack of concern about his appearance, which I think is villagery.
Jane - volume says theyāre town Jane has generally felt ācomfortableā with the thread, moreso than I think she generally would as scum.
Everyone else
Derps - [shrug emoji]. I suck at reading Derps.
Gaja - has like two posts as of when I started this list, Iāve seen them typing a bit since so maybe theyāve done something AI but for now theyāre true null.
Appel - I donāt remember anything from this slot, Iāve seen a lot of people townreading it and I still donāt totally get why
Gorta - I donāt remember anything from this slot
Alice - Iāve mentioned this a couple times already but the narrowness in her reads is Notable and there are a few places where her intentions donāt line up with her actions (e.g. wanting to be in Allies chat with me, who she hasnāt really made a read on, rather than any of the people she thinks is town)
Italy - has done literally nothing game-relevant and for all he claims that thatās NAI and he doesnāt have meta, I donāt actually think thatās true.
Mode - WOLF WOLF WOLF 
More seriously, Mode has an incredibly contrasting meta as town and as scum and he is clearly in his scum meta this game. While his actions as any alignment donāt really make sense, his actions right now donāt even not make sense in a villagery way.
PoE>scumreads
sometimes the evils just kinda get by
also b cause marshal in randomizre did well with it
Yes, but the visceral dissatisfaction of it hasnāt really hit me until now ā because I realize that D1 is about to end.
It felt like we had more time and now we donāt.
what does null mean?
This is an interesting post but I donāt feel like it goes into depth enough
yes i know arete did this joke earlier on let me have this
I donāt know how many scum have it but the apostle is the lone cultist without one
I mean since we have nothing else to go on sure
but this is a weak read and should be subject to quick change
no
lotta content in few posts
I want you to ISO her slot during the night because I feel like thereās a plenty of content from her slot.
Same thing here. ISO him, he has 14 or however many posts.
Also Arete, you know what strikes me as odd? The fact that you only bother to define your TRās/TLās here.
Even Seth who is under heavy suspicion is in this amorphous pile of āeveryone elseā for you. I donāt like it.
Everyone!
Tell me the name of one person you would nightvig at this moment?
(Was gonna say I hope is NKāed but thatās a bad question)