I do like that people are paying attention to my ISOs now. It seemed like before they were being ignored, but I explained it in my ISO. I pointed out that there were some posts that looked like solving and they seemed genuine. That’s what I meant there, I was having second thoughts about Gilbert being scum because of those posts. I am also more confident in Helen being scum right now (hence my vote earlier) and think Gilbert deserved an extra day to save said slot if town. I believe Gilbert can pull said slot out of the PoE if that slot is indeed town. Like Gilbert is still PoE, but he’s at the top of the PoE list for me.
I will have to check out your more recent posts and give you a second shot, but I do hope tomorrow that you can try to improve your posting. I want to see less sidelining and more solvey stuff from you as well.
The king would first have to know who the scum are, so it’s possible the king votes his own scum team over bad reads, which is why gscum should be priority.
Which comments? I assume you mean the Gilbert read, but I hope that I explained it as best I could.
I will give the slot a second look, but I wouldn’t suggest voting there if we could after the claim. Is there any way for a noble to confirm themselves? If so then Jane should try to do it.
If you flip GK and got poisoned for shitty plays then it’s not their fault. You have been scummy and this post is scummy as well. The best way to clear your name is to work on solving this game. If you are the GK you will start solving.
exactly this (also I am getting towny vibes from Isabel)
Ok, Alan, can you explain why a good king would do this in good faith? When I went to sleep the lynch was always in Helen/Jane and then it became always in Helen/Gilbert. Mary was never an option, so if you were good you should have held the GT.
I also get towny Alice vibes from this post (I still need to ISO Alice)
I would say it depends. If It’s a repeat offender let them try to convince you not to execute them, but if it’s a first timer ask them the same thing you asked me.
That sounds fair, but I would still ask first if you haven’t jailed them before
“They forgot who the King was, they must be scum.”
“They used a specific pronoun, they must be scum.”
“They asked to someone to give reads, they must be town.”
Yeah, no wonder why the town play on this site is ass. People here literally have no idea how to read others without meta. This is pure conjecture and while I dislike Gilbert’s slot this is likely due as people generally use he as a pronoun and feels like gasping at straws.
Reading thread now. Still wanting to lynch Gilbert as his ISO has no pushing and has spent much of the game making vague townreads and just defended himself.
Frankly there’s no point in wasting a lynch on the King until the very end. Just poison him and if we have no Butlers then just treat him like Thomas 1 and put him on ignore.
This site in general is terrible when it comes to replacing out people that need to be replaced out, though.
Zone basically vig’d a PR over a grudge in SFoL63 and then further threatened to gamethrow more the entire game and was not replaced. Wazza in FoL30 literally was not playing for three days and was just prodging and it took until EoD3 to replace him. Esq in WYMII was just posting questions about acronyms on the thread and was only replaced d3.
I think you’re absolutely right here concerning what you’ve said about replacements.
If you don’t play the game you’ve signed up for, then why sign up in the 1st place?
It’s selfish and inconsiderate towards everyone as it makes it harder for people to read you when you’re not trying to play the game.
