Did you even read my reply to you?
I explained my Gilbert read for people and it seems everyone ignored it
Donāt ever ask me to explain something and act like it doesnāt exist
If youāre not that settled on Gilbertās alignment then why not keep trying to solve it instead of leaving him like this?
Entire exchange there, especially the wording, feels W/W with a wolf telling the other to village up or get bussed rather than a villager trying to genuine solve their slot.
Because I canāt with whatās there currently. If Gilbert is town they will start solving if they arenāt they will freeze up and keep defending themselves. This is not something I can do as of now. I can look at his new posts closer, but thatās about it.
How is it W/W from your PoV?
I specifically said that Gilbert is a null in the PoE for me. If they donāt improve they die. Whatās so hard to understand about that assessment?
Spoilers, they have just frozen and spent much their time in the thread making shoddy defenses.
In Helen/Gilbert worlds I always want to see Helen flip first because they are my highest SR as of now. I need to re-eval Jane and look at Gilbertās recent posts, but Helen is the wolfiest of the trio
Then they might be a wolf, I need to take a look at their recent posting. I thought they were showing potential though
Expand on these please. Iād like to know which posts/reads youāre referring to with Sarah and Helen as well.
The way he claimed his class was NAI imo. After Nicolas outted his results, he had all the time in the world to form a convincing fakeclaim if heās a wolf.
Why havenāt you yet?
Iām skimming through Andyās d2 and the worst thing they have done isā¦ not do much of anything. He doesnāt have a lot of content to go off of.
Posted Lucy and Susanās final reads but didnāt comment on them or do anything with them.
Kinda feels like they were trying to look useful.
Says at one point heās going to try to read Thomas 2.0 butā¦ still hasnāt.
RT shit goes on for ~15 posts
His catch-up post (Post #78 in ISO) is fine
We werenāt anywhere close to quickhammering. This post from Edmond is NAI imo. Also Iāve read the last sentence a few times and every time I read it it feels like a scumslip but I know it isnāt bc scumslips like this are bullshit.
Donāt know why he didnāt say āScum I think here would take the opportunity to vote out a villager who everyone thinks is redcheckedā or something similar.
I like this post.
Iām so flip-floppy on this.
I donāt see them mention Sarah anywhere else in their ISO and this feels like it came out of nowhere.
The last sentence justā¦ feels so villagery and genuine though lmao
All of Andyās conclusions in this post are fleshed out andā¦ seemā¦ real? Good vibes too.
I want him to go back and quote what heās referencing when he says āsome posts from [player] ping me as [scummy/townie]ā for all of these reads, though.
Finish these please, or at least give me some thoughts.
He didnāt feel uncomfortable in his interaction with the Prince.
Meh. Mehmehmehmeh
Iām torn
Honestly liking Andy a lot more after reading through this. I also just checked my d1 reasonings for disliking the slot and I absolutely was too focused on looking for wolftells.
But his slot still hasnāt done all that much tbh, and I still believe in some of the things I said d1, such as his useless Thomas interactions, as well as:
^ This one is a positive
Thomas also made a good point that it looks like he could potentially have been TMIāing old Thomas as not groupscum.
I think a lot of the reason I disliked Andy today was because of the observer info though, and it biased and skewed my view on him afterwards. It woulda been nice if it wasnāt outted how it was outted, but I canāt change the past
Iām not sold on Andy being a villager atm, and Iām also not sold on him being a wolf.
There are things that ping me from both sides of the spectrum and I really want to talk to other people about this because Iāll just keep going back and forth in my head.
This was supposed to be a catchup post and I went on a bigass tangent and Iām now tired as hell and gonna chillax
Just skimmed the rest to catch up rq
Because you begin saying that you believe that Gilbertās slot has a chance of flipping W, then mentioning that they could dig themselves out of it and saying youād rather lynch Helen or Jane over them without further interacting with them. Youāre not talking about the potential of them being a villager here, and the end absolutely reeks of a wolf telling their bud to village up or be bussed.
Also where the hell is Peter?
He dropped off the face of the planet.
All heās done today is focus on a single individual and thatās nagl.
I kind of just want him to bounty someone and then see if this is a Cult or Unseen game and slot him into a conf!starting BD if itās the latter.
I tried making it clear that I thought they had the potential of being a villager. Take this for example, in which I say that I think they made some towny thoughts.
I did lay the breadcrumbs down if you read between the lines
I think my conclusion does support the things I said in my ISO of Gilbert
I have no idea.
Iām trying to remember what he did this game.
Noble claim if I remember correctly.
Defending Thomas isnāt exactly towny. He had literally no reason to townread it.
Would you mind if I made a condensed post talking about Gilbertās recent posts or should I just make a full on ISO of Gilbertās last 50 posts?
Condense it.
I kind of see what you are talking about with Gilbert. I think the slot was being solvier earlier and thus thought there was potential for them to be town, but I donāt see it in their last 40-50 posts. Itās just more of the same stuff. I thought the slot would do more tbqh. I want to make a better ISO post on this point later, but for now I hope this is fine
