hmm, i was willing to be more lenient on Susan about that, considering in my first few games i did idiotic things and appreciated the correction. however, i appreciate the different viewpoint you two have presented here and i can see how it makes sense.
Ah, the thread is finally at a reasonable size. This is quite liberating.
At least Thomas isnāt a killing class. We would have a big problem on our hands if that were the case. Heās still an annoyance, but at least he canāt gamethrow with his night action.
Anyway.
I think Edmondās posts have been sufficiently free-flowy and free of formulaic progression. He looks good tonally as well, and he is not afraid to combine shitposting with a few meaningful questions + pieces of analysis.
I donāt think heās at a high enough level to justify towncoring, but he is elevated above null. The primary issue I have with him is that he spent the first half of his ISO talking to Thomas and about Thomas. Like I said earlier, a wolf could easily do this, knowing they are set up to fail. It would also elevate their postcount.
Surely, there are also villagers who did this, though. You people really should have realized that it was a waste of time as soon as Thomas began to spam pepegas and failed to relent. But I digress.
Youāre doing it again.
Stop having the same thoughts as me.
i realized my mistake as the thread went on and i saw how absolutely anti-town and frankly disgusting his behaviour was from either alignment. he distracted me, and i hate it, but it is what it is now and i canāt uninteract with him however much iād like to.
The fact my top two townreads seem to be mindmelding in real time is inspiring.
While I am grateful to Helen for showing me how to ignore people, her entire ISO is five Thomas-related posts and nothing else.
However, the first post about Thomas looks ratherā¦ creative for a wolf. I am referring to the post with the images. Absolutely not something Helen should be cleared for, but just like with Edmond, it puts Helen slightly above null for me.
so far i believe emma has had a strong entrance to the thread even though itās quite early. actually analyzing from the start? i havenāt seen that in ages! iām not going to throw you a townlean this soon until i see more from you, but i will say it is a good look.
Interesting.
The ISO contains no attempts to analyze anyone.
The posts about Thomas, especially the seventh and eighth post, come across as outright lies. They are performative. Geoffrey does not appear to truly care about Thomasā conduct within the thread. Their comments about the thread being inflated were also throwaway remarks, rather than anything with even a shred of passion.
This opening string of posts hits quite a few notes I would expect from a mafioso attempting to enter this messy thread.
unlike you im throwing them a townlean tbh, i like their posts alot. But again you should always re eval often
tbh early game anyone solving is townlean
what are ur reads like?
iād like to, i just canāt let myself do it when their iso is still in the single digits. thereās very little doubt i wonāt end up townleaning them though.
Ivo W
thomas V
achive ppl V(u, emma (some other person I donāt remember name of)
active
any reasoning for this one, kinda curious. Someone said something bout em earlier but not sure if it was u
here
iām not gilbert, but the only gripe i have with ivo is that i they were asked multiple times for reads when they were still active and ignored that. itās not a large issue as i suppose they could have missed it, but itās an issue nonetheless.
I just got here and am reading up on the thread now. Iāll throw you a bone though, I think Thomas is towny based on jokes, which is sad because what he/she is doing is terrible for the threadstate. Andyās opener was awful, but I think they deserve a chance to try and act towny. I am currently at post 180
ah so it was you, while i tend to agree with normal wolf, i know i pulled that shit as town a lot, i got called out for it by Mathblade once and that annoyed the shit out of me cause i was genuinely busy