SFoL17.5 - The Carnival - Psychopathic King wins! - Icibalus Loses\!

I also forgot to submit an action

That being said I donā€™t think Simon would fall back on that as his claim so I trust him

/vote Eevee

riperino in unseen

Unless you think itā€™s safer to just nolynch and risk another kill

But I trust Simonā€™s noaction claim

Also wait that means they didnā€™t get a second convert off

So it basically has to be Eevee or a new MM

And there is no way in hell thereā€™s a new MM, the game would be over with a whole new Unseen

Or it means Hippo yolobombed and hit the last unseen, because they had extra death immunity.

And i donā€™t like the eevee lynch, there should be absolutely no way for eevee to kill, so we canā€™t lose to him

Immunity would be a shit buff

Yeah but the buff shouldnā€™t have really happened in this first place
Vulgard was getting lynched 100% that day

1 Like

I agree 100%

Although, that being said, the game was (as per usual) almost too easy otherwise

I can feel this coming down to MyLo if we hang Eevee
Me and You and Simon because whichever of you is scum will kill Wolfy

LyLo, rather

Uhā€¦

Tbh I was holding back till Orange claims info, to telling Marl that he overdramatizes the situation.

Simon shouldnā€™t know that I consider natural ā€œI forgot to semd an actionā€ as very townie.

Orange knows it, but I also know how busy they are rn, so theirs claim could be fair as well.

We canā€™t lose if itā€™s eevee
/Vote Orange

Thereā€™s a big difference between Simon not checking and Orange not checking
The person who said they forgot to check is more likely to be town, as itā€™s a gigantic gambit (as scum) because the other person couldā€™ve successfully gotten a check off - leading to their demise.

The only way I can see the scum claiming that they forgot to do their check is if the other had said it first, giving town no leads, trying to buy a night.

The first person*

The funny fact is that if Orange claimed Unseen check on Simon, I would of sided with Simon. (Also cause Orange is more likely to get converted).

There was one more tinfoil idea in my head wich came straight from paranoia.
Why did Marl ask to compare Orange and Them?
Why not Dama who was confirmed?

There was a tinfoil idea of Marl-Orange scumteam wich ofc when compared would give ā€œsameā€ result.
Orange would then claim BD check on Simon, proceed to lynch me, kill whoever and win.

Tho it does seem unlikely that there is 2 unseen with what Ici just said.

1 Like

Mostly because I know Iā€™m BD
I would have been fine with him comparing himself with Dama also

I would just like to reiterate that weā€™re looking for the n1 / n2 convert, and ici confirmed that the buff had nothing to do with the unseenā€™s membership

Yeah but iā€™m trying to hang orange now because Iā€™m pretty sure heā€™s the scum

also, if you do the math and there was a new mastermind after vulgard died - Unseen would have 3 members right now (aka majority)

So thatā€™s not an option either