Alright, that more or less makes sense.
The thing is, people’s reads are most likely going to change from D1.
I wouldn’t really find it weird if someone wanted to heal X on D1, but actually healed Y even on N1, because there’s obviously going to be more content to go off of.
Why does it concern you, though? Do you think that nothing you’ve posted so far has been AI?
Addendum: Seth claimed to TR you off of tone.
Which is not something I explicitly agree on, but I’m curious to hear your answer to my question.
Just find it odd that most people are scumleaning me and then Seth is just randomly defending me and saying I am town, like I appreciate it, but it seems way too odd in these circumstances
Mmm, that’s an interesting statement.
I wouldn’t really be concerned about certain people TRing me while most others SL me if I was in the same spot? I’d just do my best to prove to the group that SL’s me that I’m town – but that’s just me.
Unless you think it’s a pocket attempt or something.
Idk
I just find it kinda odd and convenient, but I guess I’ll take it for now, atleast someone believes I’m town
I’m gonna go catch up posts, and maybe do some ISOing if I have time, I feel like I’m gonna change my reads at the EoD
I think excitement is likelier to come from noobtown than noobscum
Ok tinfoil
Scum PK wouldn’t say this if he’s aware he shouldn’t do that since him giving his opinion without saying that is worth more town cred
Would GS say that? I don’t know but then self doubt is consistant so I think it comes from town
Commiting to reads is good
I don’t know I just like the fact he voices his reads and there’s a low amount of them
I like that less though, but it’s the play not the motivation
Oh something that ticks me off, he isn’t that isolated in thread? That’s weirdish
I think like “seems” reads only ever come from noobtown whereas “unsure” is weirder
TL
I don’t have enough SRs that’s tilting me
Why are we Townreading/Scumreading people day 1 again?
There is literally barely any proof right now to say someone is TR or SR.
I can have reads
without having mech proof
yeah we cant do vca since no lyncherinoo but eh
tbh
Outside of NK and EK, there is only two groupwolves d1
harder to build associations and since there is no voting, we cant really do VCA at all.
Its a good idea to set up a towncore/townleans from people you read d1, so you can lower the PoE of potential wolves in your eyes
Tbh
VCA is something ive been picking up, and was attempting to do in WoW FM with limited success.
I thought we weren’t supposed to townread/scumread people day 1 unless under very specific situations?
It depends on multiple factors. Meta, tone and others based on ISO to figure out likely alignment.
That’s literally how I’ve been feeling so far.
Most of the people that have posted are my TL’s – which is precisely what happened in my last two games. I’m somewhat skeptical that groupscum is in nulls this game as well.
Because reads are the only thing we have on D1 and they bring discussion, which makes the thread progress.
There’s no proof but there are people’s stances and opinions, which are important on their own.
At this point unless the scum do or say something really incriminating, all we have is educated guesses and reads d1.
Also I think Unknown’s recent posts are looking better than their opener did.
Like I said previously, my main concerns from them were the invest/cop/healer question + that one post about “not being groupscum”.
But I can follow through with their recent explanations and logic.
mmmmm, actually, getting extra good material from catching up on some things, I think I have some new reads ready, but I still need to catch up for now
What?
The only games you’ve played are SFoL 61 and 61.5 and you were scum in one of them.
While I agree that it’s similar to 61, I don’t see how you think it’s also similar to 61.5.
Do you not remember that 61.5 literally had consensus readlist up until D4/D5 where I practically openwolfed.
On D3, the only suspect was a Prince claiming Priest.
The thread felt stagnant on D1, just like it did now.
