Thing Game - Joy Flavor - Game Over - Town Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#3073

I have a question, why would people kill cloned if he is known to tunnel townies?

#3074

I need a break, but I want answers for that by the time I get back

#3075

I guess he did have WiM, but why not convert/use him to push bs?

#3076

maybe itā€™s specifically because of that reason - he was mostly TRā€™d, wasnā€™t he? despite his incorrectly placed votes.

#3077

I never wanted Cloned lynched personally. However, I saw strong parallels between the mafia games he has played and how he has played now.

1 Like
#3078

A cloned kill just seems unoptimal in my opinion

#3079

I donā€™t think Iā€™ve ever seen Cloned as a wolf actually. Iā€™ve seen him in other games, though, and I mistook his kind of low WiM for wolfiness because I was comparing them to the PokĆ©mon 9er where he definitely had WiM more similar to how he has in this game.

#3080

I agree with this. Even if we were mostly TRing him, he was acting weird enough that people might have started suspecting him. Or if not that, then he could still cause town to go in wrong directions with his theories. I would think someone like Windward would have been a better kill.

1 Like
#3081

actually, this brings me to a weird question - why wasnā€™t I the night kill? I correctly SRā€™d Appel, and earlier than Cloned, but Iā€™m not dead.

#3082

oh lol, you noticed the same thing

1 Like
#3083

I was totally expecting to lose you this day.

#3084

tbh Iā€™ve only been nightkilled once by mafia lol

#3085

Iā€™ve been wondering this for awhile also. I donā€™t know that Iā€™ve seen Cloned as wolf.

#3086

actually, I didnā€™t get NKā€™d in the last mountainous game because my reads were completely wrong and mafia wanted me to push an ML in LyLo (but I refused to vote and handed the responsibility over to Leafia lol)

if the reason Iā€™m still alive is similar to in Shortnight 2, then it means my reads are probably wrong. The last thing I said before Appel got yote was that ATN was the next scummiest, and here I find myself starting to doubt that read.

2 Likes
#3087

Tinfoil: Whysper is apart of the Italian mafia in real life

2 Likes
#3088

I think it just means I need to start to the best of my abilities with a blank slate and reevaluate again to see what Iā€™ve been missing. I donā€™t want to lead the town into ruin again by tunnelling town, and if I get correct reads, at least Iā€™d deserve to die by them.

#3089

Haha :slight_smile:

#3090

anyway, back to studying for a while, but Iā€™ll check in again before I sleep. ping me if you want me to respond to something!

#3091

Whysper what do you think of PKR?

#3092

I had SLā€™d him as Moon. But after the reveal, I felt he gradually improved. Then I was kind of giving him a pass because he talked about being busy. But now itā€™s been longer than just a day and it does feel like heā€™s slowed down again as ATNo brought up.

Also, I quoted that one post of Appelā€™s with her PoE. She had both EVO and PKR with question marks. I get this feeling that one of those is a wolf. I think she would have included one partner in her PoE. She did this before in Watch Your Mouth. She had her partner Eli as a SR and her other partner Derps kind of in the middle but later as TR. And I think she would put them with a question mark here to give her leeway to adjust the read. But to not make just that partner stand out, she put question marks on two people.

2 Likes