ToS Mafia - Day 8 - (3/19) [Town wins!]

If he were to RT, he would actually back down eventually

1 Like

His play throughout this game aside from credit karma was very town
I agreed with him against Jake. Lots of mindmeld
and my read only got stronger when someone linked me to read Candlelight. I think his meta is same here

So, he could still be witch here and his meta would be distinctly the same.

I don’t see anything for T!Arete other than ā€œin their town metaā€

i don’t think there’s a chance in hell that marshal is lookout

but marshal is hardpushing when he would have backed down by now if he were town

he at least would have retracted his lookout claim

Backed down if it was a RT?
Would he back down if he was actually LO with this result?

It’s just, obvious.

This isn’t an answer, it’s just describing the other argument.

Why do you specifically think Arete is scum.

Literally everything Arete has done has been town indicative. It begs the question, ā€œIs it faked?ā€ but you can’t actually SR Arete without TMI.

Marshal likely doesn’t have TMI, but he’s had agenda since game opening.

2 Likes

again, no way in hell marshal is LO

ā€œIt’s just obviousā€ isn’t a reason someone is town.
You cannot convince someone who has never played a game with another player that that player is town/scum because you know them or it’s ā€œjust obviousā€. All I have to go off of here is my reads. What I think. I’m sorry you disagree but trying to tell me I’m obviously wrong for meta reasons I can’t relate to at all does nothing

I hate that if were right were only getting the witch, but I’d love to resolve this.

/Vote Marshal

Why do read him as scum though?!

You’re avoiding my question like it’s the plague.

You’re just telling me my reasoning is bad you’re not explaining your viewpoint.

you might take it as a joke, but marshal also voted arete at the start of the game, like he wanted arete out and thought he could mask his vote
or i’m just looking too far into this shit

1 Like

jmw: all i have to go off of here is my reads
also jmw: why are you clearing people purely based off of their reads

Arete started attacking themselves at one point. ā€œWhy are people defending meā€ and such. It looks to me like they’re trying too hard to look town. It’s irritating that people just wave their hand at my reads because it’s obvious, it’s their town/scum meta. Well guess my reads are worth significantly less because it’s my first game with most of these people, that’s sure motivating

You’re not, that’s the ā€œMarshal has had agenda since game startā€ observation I made a few posts up.

Meta reads are different good strawman though